JayneStars.com logo

Funn’s Thoughts: The Roundabout Plot of the Confidant

By on December 6, 2012

Funn’s Thoughts: The Roundabout Plot of the Confidant thumbnail

Funn’s Note: The following are not episode recaps but are ramblings and torrents of disbelief for The Confidant <大太監>. All merely personal opinion.

Watched until episode 22….

Let’s forget about episode 20. Or even episode 21. Go straight to episode 22 and then let’s forget about everything that has developed since episode 20 because episode 22 is back to square 1. I am frustrated at how the writer is bending his or her or their backs to make Cixi the good guy. When Cian seems nice, now in episode 22 we are told.. dang dang dang dang …. those are gong rolls by the way…Cian is back to “up to no good” stance. She has never really felt sorry for what she did and she says with gritted teeth “My biggest mistake is to beg for forgiveness from that Cixi. I am an Empress Dowager for god’s sake!! Why am I subjecting myself to that insulting humiliation of being second to that Cixi?!” and then she vows to destroy Cixi by destroying everyone around her, starting with An De Hai. So I was wrong. It may seem An De Hai never turned back, he in fact has a good relationship with his few best friends, best being Linying of course and An De Hai seems to know his days is up as he says to Lianying “If anything should happen to me, all my money is yours, I only ask you take care of Siu Chai for me, as I would take care of Sin Yung for you if anything bad should happen to you.” It means An De Hai is surely dying in the next few episodes thanks to Cian.

And this I do not get. Why on earth is Cian back to no good when viewers must be pitying her by now and wondering why that Cixi is so stubborn and vindictive and mean? Well simple! Like I said series is bending its back to show Cixi the misunderstood one and so by showing Cian is back to no good meaning she has never really changed or regretted her actions, it shows Cixi was right to doubt her and then to boycott her and then to treat her badly! Simple! To TVB all conflict is 1 + 1 equals the number TVB wants you to believe. I hate that sudden development. By trying to justify Cixi, and by making Cian the unrelentless small minded petty stupid jealous woman she is, shows how simplistic this series is. I want Cian to have good and bad side, but that is not to be. I want Cixi to be wrong but she is always right. There is nothing complicated about Cixi and Cian. And that is why this series’ storytelling is god awful if not for the performances.

Take for instance another line of story. The eunuch natural right to a loving relationship. I GET IT! OF COURSE I GET IT! Eunuch even if without his manhood deserves love, craves love, finds love, has love and is natural to love and want to be loved. I! GET! IT! So why is this theme being repeated again and again and again to the point that Cixi even approves of Lianying and Sin Yung OPENLY “dui sik” meaning intended for one another but not marrying as that would be a scandal. Cian begs Cixi to let An De Hai marry his Siu Chai. Seung Hei looking at princess He Shuo who is back by the way, longingly and sure enough will probably go back to love mode. Cian begging Seung Hei to forgive her for her sins of tearing the love birds apart. I suspect she was acting only in light of the ending. And in one unforgivably stupid dialogue and scene which is well acted but still stupid, An De Hai, and everyone laments the fact that “Why the emperor can do anything he wants, marry the woman he loves and we eunuchs can’t even love openly? It is unfair!”

Stupid, because he is the emperor. He is your master. And didn’t they for 2 episodes try to persuade Cixi to let the emperor marry his Bao Yin? Does that show the emperor can marry anyone he loves? No, he still has to beg, pout, be angry, etc before he can marry Bao Yin. And we all know how Prince Gong threatened Cixi with that letter (remember that letter?) before Cixi agrees to the marriage. No, emperor can’t do anything in here without mommy says yes and mommy won’t say yes before Prince Gong go nuclear with his threats. But best was when Cixi threatened Prince Gong back, Prince Gong said, “You can threaten me all you want, if I fall, I will be sure to drag you with me to hell”.

What a man! But what a stupid scene for the eunuchs. And that was when I threw my hands up in the air and scream “I!!!!!!!!!! GET!!!!!!!!!!! IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!”

Now can we move on? Nope because back to Cian and back to square 1.

This series was amazing in episode 20, but the rest was “can do, can do” or in Chinese “ma ma fu fu”. It will be ending soon but from the looks of it Cixi will never be the villain. She is the good guy. She won’t go crazy or bad. But will this series end with Tong Zhi’s death? I do not doubt Cian’s love for Tong Zhi even if she is manipulating his love in a strange non manipulating way. Since Cian is dying soon, I suppose she will in TVB world die when Tong Zhi dies which means Tong Zhi’s death will be her wake up call? That she should stop being so damn petty? Maybe not. I am giving TVB too much credit in being subtle and yet meaningful.

But both Cian and Cixi are both stubborn and both petty in frustrating ways which is not giving this series a chance to tell a bigger conflict, a bigger story. Right now despite the wide angles of Heng Dian’s fake Forbidden City which is really the best thing in this series apart from the performances, the story sucks by not realizing its full potential.

And go back 2 episodes ago, where got Palace choose “sau lui” at night or so early in the morning? Easy to explain. TVB probably could only book that time for filming. Heng Dian is darn busy. And in some shots I can hear loud chatters (probably fans by the side? Can’t the director say SHUT UP?!) and in one shot, I can hear loud music blaring, probably another series filming some dance scenes. In a way it is a very noisy and happening place, in a way quite distracting. Destroys the feel of the place being the foreboding Forbidden Palace. I am sure in the Mainland China series you can hear all those sounds but since voices are dubbed, you hear echo. In TVB, credit to them for maintaining their integrity in NOT dubbing or rather by recording on site, I don’t mind the sounds. It was just funny in a distracting way or maybe distracting in a funny way which is a more apt description.

For a series with so many people, other people are not getting enough screen time or character development. The usually loud and annoying Natalie Tong gave a subdued performance but she has so little screen time, which may explain why I like her in here thus far. Nancy Wu did a good job but her role is getting lesser and lesser and less and less important. Even Lianying stopped being important. In fact everyone seems underused. I am not sure where all the time went. All I know is people walk in and out of a scene. Chan Fuk is back and that is annoying. He should be dead by now. A lot of people should be dead by now but recycling villains is seriously boring when these villains can’t do much.

At this point, this series survives on performances. But if you look at the story, it is standard ordinary stuff with some stupid moments thrown in and some amazingly idiotic dialogue with some very difficult to understand words just so to make it sound like it was back in those days when it the end it sounds pretentious. I want to love this series but right now, I am liking it for very specific reasons. And the story isn’t one of them. A suggestion to TVB; why not try following the real history? Because real history in this case makes more drama than this insipid so called drama. Waste of talent for the actors.

I hope when this series is done with the Cian conflict, it will show us a better more bigger conflict to end it with a bang. Or like I said, end it with Tong Zhi’s death to make Cian realise whatever she planned are just plain silly and a waste of time.

Related Commentaries on “The Confidant”

This commentary is written by Funn Lim and was originally posted at www.point2e.com

JayneStars Media LLC reserves all copyrights. Reproduction in whole or in part without written permission is prohibited. By using the JayneStars website, you accept and agree to our Terms and Conditions of Use.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Related Articles

  • Review: "The Confidant" (By Miriamfanz)(21)
  • Ending Spoilers for "The Confidant" Revealed(28)
  • Synopsis of "The Confidant"(27)
  • “The Confidant" Ending Leaves Questions Unanswered(40)
  • Funn's Thoughts: The Baffling Non-Existent Palace Struggle in "The Confidant"(47)
  • The Great Five Eunuchs of “The Confidant”(34)
  • Funn's Thoughts: The End of An Dehai(32)
  • Funn's Thoughts: Life and Death in "The Confidant"(20)
  • Funn's Thoughts: Michelle Yim is a Bland Empress Cixi(41)
  • “The Confidant” Receives Red Carpet Treatment(92)

  • Readers' Comments (28)

    1. gotcha says:

      seems to me the ladies in the pic are in dire need of facials, lymphatic facials should be good

    2. mito says:

      Funn, off topic, how do you find The Life Of A Sentinel with this?

      I think it is pretty related, not the era. But the epic mess.

      Hoping that someone eunuch is not eunuch …

      • Funn Lim says:

        I can’ compare since I confess, I didn’t watch The Life Of A Sentinel when it was aired. That bad??

        This current series is like a public service announcement of ERHACLT

        AKA Eunuchs Are Human AND CAN LOVE TOO

        Every single episode.

        “Hoping that someone eunuch is not eunuch …”

        What do you mean?

      • djojs says:

        The Life of a Senttinel was way much better than this boring slow series called the Confident.

    3. Jen says:

      Funn, i share your sentiments. This series is confusing and isn’t very well written.

      • Funn Lim says:

        The next episode is worse with the sudden changes of some key characters. That merits a new writeup. I hate what they’re doing to An De Hai.

        • Jen says:

          I find it silly that they are changing history, as well the characters of each historical figure as we know it. If they changed it to provide us with an entertaining story line, it’s fine. Unfortunately, here I feel like they are just using the characters as a base to the storyline and changing each character to suit the script, ie they are just using the characters name in the series, but there is too little historical accuracy.
          I’m not sure what keeps me going though, as I am still watching the series religiously every time it airs.

    4. Apple says:

      Question: why aimees character is pregos? I must of missed something

      • Funn Lim says:

        Definitely not thanks to Seung Hei! She was married off to a general remember? For a few years, and she returned to the palace as a widow and pregnant. The pregnancy will kill her and guess what? No worries Seung Hei to the rescue. I must ask what does Seung Hei have to do before he is beheaded?

        1. romance the princess? No
        2. Elope with the princess? No
        3. Abort the princess’ child without permission? No

        So I suppose he is superman.

        I hate it when he tells I think Linying how much he loves the princess and all and so he had to abort her child for her safety and I was thinking maybe she fell for the general and since general died she wants to leave a child/bloodline for the general? Because you know Seung Hei you ain’t the only one who can love and be loved by the princess.

        And guess what?

        Next scene we are told princess was never happy being married to the general who impliedly didn’t treat her well since she never loved him and so they never got on. The child was her only hope to normalcy and at that point everything Seung Hei did was justified and I was likes screaming OH LET THEM GET MARRIED THEN!

        The plot is getting worse and worse and worse. The Confidant is the best series for TVB? Then the rest is crap.

        And talking about crap, I regret not continuing my recap for SSSS because it is crap.

        • Funn Lim says:

          And crap makes for great recap.

          And that is Funn says so.

        • chps says:

          Haha I havn’t watched the confidant or ssss bar the first 2 episodes each so I can’t really comment. But is SSSS that bad? I actually really like some of the cast members like damien, mary and elena and I don’t mind Tavia.

        • Apple says:

          Ahahha Thanksss=))))))

        • Jen says:

          oh yeah i thought that the reason why the princess insisted on keeping the baby was because she loved the general so much that she wanted to save his baby. gosh nothing makes sense here!

        • miriamfanz says:

          After Raymond Lam as Ironman in HAL, what’s wrong with Raymond Wong as Superman? :P

        • Chi says:

          In ep 25, we’re told that the Princess was in fact madly in love with the General & had long forgotten Seung Hei. Sad for Sueng Hei.

        • Funn Lim says:

          Yeah just watched that. Not sad at all. What a traitor that Seung Hei is. And so stupid. First eunuch to die a terrible death and deserves it!

    5. vann says:

      for me The Confident is still the best series to watch.

      series to w

    6. Uni says:

      not only is the series historically inaccurate but the entire plot requires revision.

      • sandcherry says:

        Agree with the above comments. There is nothing logical to watch except the interactions between the five eunuchs, especially Pang Sam Shun (by Chan Kwok Pong).

    7. Veejay says:


      I think there is a mistake up there,
      “My biggest mistake is to beg for forgiveness from that Cian. I am an Empress Dowager for god’s sake!!

      I think you meant Cixi right instead of begging forgiveness from that Cian?

      • Funn Lim says:

        Yes thanks for noticing it! But I can’t revise this so errr.. I can review my own original posting at my blog!

    8. Jen says:

      There are too many “Uh what the ****?” scenes in this series. Especially for a non comedic historical series.

    9. westnorth says:

      Power Chan as Pang Sam-shun comment:-

      AiYa ! this is TVB entertainment drama not attending History Class

      • miriamfanz says:


        After Three Kingdoms RPG, I give up on TVB & historical accuracy. Just watch as a drama and you’ll enjoy it immensely. If you want real history, you’re better off watching Mainland series. Or can read here: http://casualtvb.blogspot.ca/2012/11/historical-context-confidant-characters.html

        • sandcherry says:

          Actually, I could accept the storyline of “3 Kingdoms RPG” because it was meant to be a comedic drama series, not a traditional, ancient, historical drama series. However, “The Confidant” is a serious, ancient, and historical drama series, and not a comedic one.

      • Funn Lim says:

        I am not talking about historical accuracy. I am talking about logic. Logic dictates many things but they don’t apply in this series where there are jumps in story as and when it suits them.

        Empresses In The Palace was also historical inaccurate but at least mostly make sense.

    10. Hippo says:

      Problem with TVB productions is the simple fact that their scriptwriters are crap. This and SSSS are so boring, it’s sad. You can have the greatest budget, actors, and whatever, but the most important thing is to have a good story, otherwise it’s still a big fail.

      • sandcherry says:

        most important thing is to have a good story, otherwise it’s still a big fail.
        Agree with the above post absolutely. A good script and a good character can make an artiste shine in their acting. Typical examples are: Wayne Lai in “Rosy Business” and “No Regrets”, Kenneth Ma in “The Hippocratic Crush”, Michael Tse in his character as “Laughing Gor”.

    Readers are no longer able to comment on this old article.

  • Follow JayneStars

  • Who is hotter in "Eye in the Sky"? in JayneStars Asian Entertainment News on LockerDome
  • JayneStars News Subscription

    Subscribe to our free news subscription to receive daily entertainment headlines, sent straight to your e-mail account!

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

  • Most Popular Articles in 7 Days

  • Latest Headlines

    Donnie Yen Plans to Step Down from Action Films after “Ip Man 3” thumbnail

    Donnie Yen Plans to Step Down from Action Films after “Ip Man 3”

    [TV Commentary] “Eye in the Sky” Episodes 18 and 19 thumbnail

    [TV Commentary] “Eye in the Sky” Episodes 18 and 19

    (One Comment)
    Nicky Wu Celebrates Cecilia Liu’s 28th Birthday thumbnail

    Nicky Wu Celebrates Cecilia Liu’s 28th Birthday

    Rainie Yang is Tired of Being a Workaholic thumbnail

    Rainie Yang is Tired of Being a Workaholic

    TVB’s Shaw Brothers Studio to Produce 8 Films in 2015 thumbnail

    TVB’s Shaw Brothers Studio to Produce 8 Films in 2015

    Grace Chan Not Embarrassed to Bare Her Back thumbnail

    Grace Chan Not Embarrassed to Bare Her Back

    Zhang Ziyi’s Pregnancy Rumors Shot Down thumbnail

    Zhang Ziyi’s Pregnancy Rumors Shot Down

    Kate Tsui Prayed Daily While Filming for Horror Movie thumbnail

    Kate Tsui Prayed Daily While Filming for Horror Movie

    [TV Commentary] “Eye in the Sky” Episodes 16 and 17 thumbnail

    [TV Commentary] “Eye in the Sky” Episodes 16 and 17

    Tracy Chu Promoted to Lead Actress thumbnail

    Tracy Chu Promoted to Lead Actress


    Latest 500 Comments

    Click here to see the latest 500 comments from our readers.

    Submit a News Tip:

    If you have a hot or breaking news story you would like to see published on JayneStars.com, please submit a news link.

    About Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

    COPYRIGHT © 2013 JayneStars Media LLC.  All rights reserved.