JayneStars.com logo
 

Category III Film, “Vulgaria,” Remains #1 in Hong Kong Box Office

By on August 23, 2012

Category III Film, “Vulgaria,” Remains #1 in Hong Kong Box Office thumbnail

Pang Ho Cheung’s (彭浩翔) low-budget category III film, Vulgaria <低俗喜劇>, has remained in the top spot at the Hong Kong box office since its low-profile release on August 9, 2012.

Vulgaria, starring Chapman To (杜汶澤) and Ronald Cheng (鄭中基), is a sex comedy film that tells the story of a struggling movie producer who is forced to remake a new version of the soft porn film, Confessions of a Concubine <宮人我要>, after a triad leader agreed to invest in his films. It was reported that 90% of the dialogue in the film is marked by foul language, in which Pang Ho Cheung used as a device to add more “realism” to the wild scenarios presented in the movie. Vulgaria took a little less than three weeks to film the entire movie, and less than a month for Pang Ho Cheung to finish its post-production.

Despite the lack of promotion and its Category III status, Vulgaria has maintained its #1 status in the Hong Kong box office. Since its release on August 9, Vulgaria has earned a total of $11.9 million HKD from 36 locations, more than four times the gross of Hong Kong and China co-produced blockbuster, The Silent War <聽風者>, which debuted in Hong Kong at the same time as Vulgaria. Despite its success in mainland China and frequent promotions in Hong Kong, The Silent War underperformed at the box office and only earned $2.9 million HKD.

Other blockbuster films, such as Hollywood’s Madagascar 3: Europe’s Most Wanted, The Bourne Legacy, and The Dark Knight Rises, were also overshadowed by Vulgaria’s success in Hong Kong.

“The Silent War” is Predictable

The Silent War’s failure in the Hong Kong box office was unexpected. The Silent War stars box office darlings, Tony Leung (梁朝偉) and Zhou Xun (周迅).  The espionage thriller is directed by Alan Mak (麥兆輝) and Felix Chong (莊文強), the creators behind the highly acclaimed and popular Infernal Affairs <無間道> film series. Infernal Affairs broke many box office records during its theatrical run in Hong Kong in 2002, and many critics claimed that it was this film franchise that revived Hong Kong’s dying film industry.

Alan Mak and Felix Chong’s second collaborative effort, 2009’s Overheard <竊聽風雲>, also drew in large attendance records in Hong Kong. Although its sequel, Overheard 2 <竊聽風雲2>, performed slightly poorer than its predecessor, it earned enough at the box office to offset its production costs.

So why did The Silent War fail at the Hong Kong box office? Although the film is visually impressive, many critics thought the movie lacked suspense with underwhelming action sequences. The story of The Silent War, which depicts the battles between the spies of China’s Communist Party battling the Kuomintang – and with the Communist spies winning in the end – also disgruntled many Hong Kong viewers, scoffing the movie as predictable and unexciting.

However, in mainland China, The Silent War earned great success. Since its debut in August 9, the film has earned over $200 million RMB in the mainland Chinese box office, becoming one of China’s most successful summer blockbusters of the year.

Sources: QQ.com, Netease.com

This article is written by Addy for JayneStars.com.

Note: This article is written for JayneStars.com. DO NOT re-post this article on any other websites. No part of this article may be copied, reproduced, rearranged, redistributed, modified by any means or in any form whatsoever without prior written permission.  You may use the content online and for your non-commercial, personal use only. Copying these materials for anything other than your personal use is a violation of copyright laws.

Should you wish to share this article, we recommend that you: (i) link directly to the article at JayneStars.com on your website; or (ii) share this article link via social media sites such as Facebook and Twitter.

JayneStars Media LLC reserves all copyrights. Reproduction in whole or in part without written permission is prohibited. By using the JayneStars website, you accept and agree to our Terms and Conditions of Use.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,


Related Articles

  • Tony Leung Speaks About New Film, "The Silent War"(2)
  • Tony Leung and Zhou Xun as Secret Agents in "The Silent War"(36)
  • 2013 Hong Kong Film Awards: “Cold War” and “The Bullet Vanishes” Lead Nominations(2)
  • "Gf*Bf" and "Mystery" Lead 7 Nominations in 49th Golden Horse Awards(1)
  • The Trends of Mainland Chinese Cinema(20)
  • "Cold War" is Biggest Winner at 32nd Hong Kong Film Awards(26)
  • "Cold War" Biggest Winner Among Hong Kong Films in 2012(5)
  • Tony Leung Has No Nightlife; Refuses to Visit Carina Lau's Bar(25)
  • EEG Cuts Chapman To's Opportunities Due to Arrogant Attitude (27)
  • "Overheard 3" Explores Real Estate's Darkest Secrets(5)

  • Readers' Comments (25)

    1. Funn Lim says:

      With a name like Vulgaria, can we ever expect perhaps a HK film award? No? Just as I suspected! Hk cinema, still hitting the new low. Who wrote Infernal Affairs? We need another such magic!

      A pity. Chapman To and Ronald Cheng are 2 seriously funny guys who can certainly make bona fide comedy without resorting to sex and vulgarities. Stephen Chow, Micheal Hui, HK needs you!

      • Jayne says:

        Funn,
        Sex is one of those “universally relatable” things that can be a subject of endless jokes.

        The American stand-up comedy shows here are usually filled with sex and race jokes and foul language. 90% of the stand-up comedy shows I have seen are filled with these type of jokes.

        Apparently, a clean joke is really difficult to tell. Or rather not enough shock value to jolt and make you laugh nervously. Much praise to Jerry Seinfeld and Dayo Wong. Does Dayo ever resort to vulgar humor in his stand up comedy shows?

        • Funn Lim says:

          Jerry Seinfeld, very funny. Did you watch London Olympics opening? Rowan Atkinson was the funniest and not one crude joke. He did do some for his stand up comedy but it was more funny than crude.

          Dayo Wong.. maybe he has but on a more tasteful level. Comediens must have all at least talked about sex once in their routine. I love Omid Djalili and even he talked about sex but it depends on the level of vulgarity I suppose.

          But what is vulgar humour though? I know it when I am confronted with it but to describe it is difficult.

          But at least the title is interesting. Vulgaria… definitely banned in Malaysia.

      • Jayne says:

        Funn,
        The high profit margins of “Vulgaria” will likely result in a sequel and copycat films.

        Actually, the humor in Wong Jing’s movies is very crude as well. But men don’t seem to mind, as women are more sensitive to foul language.

        I hate “Family Guy” and its crudity. But many people find it funny. This may be the case for “Vulgaria.”

        • Funn Lim says:

          Never watched Family Guy. I prefer The Simpsons.

        • Funn Lim says:

          I was looking at Korean films, and I realise most korean actresses and the guys with hot bods strip and do some serious scenes with well you know what subject. The movie I hated and find distasteful is Old Boy but it is critically acclaimed. I find it vulgar not on vulgar level but on a different level of vulgarity. They also pushed the level in terms of the line between what’s right and what shouldn’t be depicted. Recently seen a film where it was about children being abused sexually and it was an interesting movie, except the director filmed the sexual abuse with children; one old actor gently scrubbing the body of a very naked young boy, a rape scene, etc. Some things should be left at suggestions and not depicted. Of course some will hail that as master storytelling, award winning stuff, but for me the line of what should be filmed and what doesn’t need to be filmed has been crossed and so make the director seems fixated on the subject and by showing so much, did not in my opinion help with understanding the issue but rather paedophiles will love a copy of the uncensored movie. I feel strongly about such depictions and a good storyteller need not show so much to tell a good story. Unfortunately film makers nowadays is probably confused between how to tell a good story and how to show a good story.

          Anyway just read Tony Scott killed himself. Why? WHY?!

        • TVBFanatic says:

          Family Guy is annoying… watch American Dad instead if you want a little more “high brow” humour in the same line.

          Futurama is my favourite “adult” north american anime.

    2. elin says:

      i wanna watch tht.. nt surprising with its name vulgaria i xpct it to reach higher heights..

    3. Jayne says:

      Mainland and Hong Kong audiences appear to have distinct tastes in their entertainment. Period dramas are extremely popular in mainland China, while Hong Kong’s audience may be more westernized and prefer stories set in modern times.

      “Vulgaria” is heavy in Hong Kong flavor (likely utilizing eye-popping new Cantonese phrases) and would be difficult to understand except for the fluent Cantonese audience.

      • witnap says:

        Agree. I know the collaboration films are good, in script and other stuff, but sometimes, they lack of the comedy part. The funny comedy part where it is so hard to find nowdays in the film

    4. elle says:

      “So why did The Silent War fail at the Hong Kong box office?”

      Different market, different needs? Perhaps the Silent War is more fitting/tailored to Mainland as target market in general.

      • Funn Lim says:

        Obviously because it is a serious movie and box office rarely likes serious depressing movies. I understand why Vulgaria is a hit but doesn’t mean I can’t rant about the state of HK cinema.

        • elle says:

          uhm. hope u didn’t feel addressed by my comment. it was merely a response on the article itself.

    5. based says:

      I’m guessing none of you have really watched Edmond Pang’s movies. He’s nothing like Wong Jing at all. Don’t generalize if you haven’t seen his work.

    6. AC says:

      Is category 3 the equivalent of a R rating in the US? There’s a lot of American comedies that are Rated R that are pretty funny so I guess it’s not that surprising it does well.

      90% foul language though? I’m not a prude but that seems over the top.

      • Addy says:

        Not really. Category III is more like an NC-17 rating.

        • AC says:

          Oh.. interesting.
          I associate NC-17 with porn so I’m guessing there are a lot of graphic scenes in this?

        • Addy says:

          I’ve never seen Love in the Puff… why did it get a Category III rating?

          NC-17 and Category III have similar requirements. For NC-17, no one under 17 can be admitted to watch, while for Cat III, no one under 18 is admitted. As for HOW the movies got those ratings, it’s a completely different story.

        • Kidd says:

          @ Addy

          Most probably the dialogue. I don’t remember any sex scene or violent scene in ‘Love in a Puff’.

    7. Kidd says:

      The name of Pang Ho Cheung alone makes me want to watch Vulgaria.

    8. Kidd says:

      You can see Vulgaria’s trailer here.

      http://asianwiki.com/Vulgaria

    9. trx workout says:

      TRX Coaching may perhaps move away frequently yet again prior to their departure

    10. Jenn says:

      I’m guessing that with the economic and work pressures of today, people in HK would opt to unwind with a comedy instead of a serious film.

    11. dude says:

      Who is that actress is she from the mainland or Hong Kong I would tap her

    12. exoidus says:

      Watch “The Silent War” the another night and it was much better than I expected. Tony acted as a comic relief in the beginng and Xun Zhou was simply great in her role.

      On a side note I think Gan TingTing had a 2 min role in this movie as well or someone that looks like her.

    Readers are no longer able to comment on this old article.

  • Follow JayneStars

  • JayneStars News Subscription


    Never miss any of JayneStars' hottest entertainment news!

    Subscribe to our free list to receive daily news headlines, sent straight to your e-mail account!

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

  • Most Popular Articles in 7 Days

  • Latest Headlines

    Kenneth Ma Caught on Date with New Girlfriend, Jackie X thumbnail

    Kenneth Ma Caught on Date with New Girlfriend, Jackie X

    (48 Comments)
    Veronica Shiu Wins Miss Hong Kong 2014 Crown thumbnail

    Veronica Shiu Wins Miss Hong Kong 2014 Crown

    (282 Comments)
    Kai Ko Tearfully Apologizes for Drug Scandal thumbnail

    Kai Ko Tearfully Apologizes for Drug Scandal

    (41 Comments)
    Chinese Actress and Former K-pop Idol Involved in Jaycee Chan Marijuana Scandal thumbnail

    Chinese Actress and Former K-pop Idol Involved in Jaycee Chan Marijuana Scandal

    (4 Comments)
    Cecilia Cheung’s Father Suffers from Broken Leg Due to Unpaid Debts thumbnail

    Cecilia Cheung’s Father Suffers from Broken Leg Due to Unpaid Debts

    (16 Comments)
    [Review] “Black Heart White Soul” (By Miriamfanz) thumbnail

    [Review] “Black Heart White Soul” (By Miriamfanz)

    (24 Comments)
    Charmaine Sheh and Chilam Cheung Do Not Share Scenes in “Triumph in the Skies” thumbnail

    Charmaine Sheh and Chilam Cheung Do Not Share Scenes in “Triumph in the Skies”

    (35 Comments)
    Chilam Cheung Preps for Malaysia Concert thumbnail

    Chilam Cheung Preps for Malaysia Concert

    (28 Comments)
    Wallace Huo Touched by Diehard Fans’ Support in Taiwan thumbnail

    Wallace Huo Touched by Diehard Fans’ Support in Taiwan

    (17 Comments)
    Miss Hong Kong 2014 Contestants Prepare for Finals Night thumbnail

    Miss Hong Kong 2014 Contestants Prepare for Finals Night

    (12 Comments)

    Latest 500 Comments

    Click here to see the latest 500 comments from our readers.



    Submit a News Tip:

    If you have a hot or breaking news story you would like to see published on JayneStars.com, please submit a news link.

    About Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy

    COPYRIGHT © 2013 JayneStars Media LLC.  All rights reserved.