Review: Bottled Passion (by Funn)

By on January 12, 2012 in NEWS, REVIEWS

pic

Bottled Passion <我的如意狼君>
TVB 2011
Producer: Lee Tim Shing
Genre: Pre-Modern Drama
Number of episodes: 21

Cast of Characters

General
Raymond Wong – Tung Boon Sin/Lee Ho
Eric Li – Lo Yat
Mok Wai Man – Uncle Sek
Yoyo Chen – Chan Yuk Fong
Unknown – Sophie (the secretary)

Tsui family
Ching Hor Wai – Lau Suet Ling/Mrs Tsui
Raymond Cho – Tsui Ping
Claire Yiu – Wan Yau
Niki Chow – Tsui Sum
Vin Choi – Tsui Onn

Hui family
Lee Sing Chueng – Hui Chun Ting
Cecilia Fong – Tam Mei Yan
Chan Jin Man – Hui Man Hon

Ko family
Samuel Kwok – Ko Siu Tong
Rebecca Chan – Tung Kwok Hing
Joel Chan – Ko Yi Tai
Traci Ip – Foo Bak Wai
Jack Wu – Yuen Yau Hin
Elaine Yiu – Ko Yi Kiu
Katy Kung – Ko Yi Nga

“A good and trusted formula should never be dismissed as same old, same old. As long as it is a good story well told, why not?” 

SPOILERS! SPOILERS! SPOILERS! 

The Title Deciphered

I get what Bottled Passion means even though the only kiss that the two main leads have in the end is a very chaste and bland one. However, the Chinese title is as if this series is a very lighthearted one. “Ngo D Yu Yi Long Guan.” Ordinarily, it means “My Ideal Husband” to be very simplistic although you can say lover, but lover seems a bit too immoral in the context but the “long” in here is that of a wolf so it kind of means “My Ideal Wolf-Husband,” which denotes a very sinister character, wolf usually denoting someone who lies. What I don’t get is this is a serious drama, never a funny moment and yet the title is way too lighthearted. For me one of the worst title. 

The Poster Deciphered

It’s a lovely poster. Color is nice; cute. So dreamy, so romantic, so romance like… yes yes BUT FOR THE WRONG SERIES!! Never had I seen a more WRONG misleading poster than for this series. At least not a bunch of heads crowding the poster or a bunch of them holding flowers smiling happily. That would be absolutely wrong. 

Summary

From Wikipedia at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bottled_Passion 

Mrs. Ko, Tung Kwok Hing (Rebecca Chan) adopted an orphan and claimed he was Ko Yi Ho (Raymond Wong), the illegitimate child that her husband Ko Siu Tong (Samuel Kwok) had been searching for many years. Tong believed Ho was more suitable than his oldest son Ko Yi Tai (Joel Chan) to be his successor, which later led to discontent. Eventually Ho was kicked out of the family, leaving him homeless. Living out alone, Ho got a taste of the bitterness in life and was determined to return home and take revenge on his adopted family under a different name Tung Bun Sin. Under his new identity, he vowed to give them a taste of losing their loved ones. Meanwhile, he meets his childhood best friend Tsui Sum (Niki Chow) again. The good-hearted Sum just took over the family soy sauce business, but Ho did not hesitate to take advantage of his long time friendship with Sum, deceiving her money and heart. Ho also plays Ko Family’s two daughters, Ko Yee Kiu (Elaine Yiu) and Ko Yee Nga (Katy Kung) in unscrupulous ways. Ho has his own mechanism and plots, which turns him into the biggest love cheater…

The summary at Wikipedia is wrong. First there is no such word as cheater. It is cheat but that is English. 

The summary itself is quite simply Mrs. Ko brought home an orphan named Lee Ho claiming him to be the long lost illegitimate son of the very rich Mr. Ko, in order to please him. She didn’t expect Mr. Ho to like the boy so much and preferred him over her own son, Yi Tai that one day she exposed the boy as a liar pretending to be the long lost son. The 8-year-old Lee Ho was cast out after being beaten, kicked and insulted. He came back and overheard how it was Mrs. Ko who arranged the adoption and decided to expose him to protect Yi Tai’s share of the inheritance. She saw Lee Ho and chased after him and ended up throwing him into the back of the cliff and he fell into the river. Some 20 years later or so, Lee Ho came back as an adult with the adopted identity of a rich privileged man named Tung Boon Sin to exact his revenge. With that, he needed to gain the trust of the Ko family by befriending them and then betraying Tsui Sum, the young owner of the local soy sauce company whose land is the one Mr. Ko desired to build his silk textile factory. What he didn’t expect was he was more involved emotionally with Tsui Sum whom he was slowly falling for as he plotted his revenge against Mrs. Ko by using her two daughters’ affections for him, whilst at the same time he searched for his childhood friend and love, Milk Candy Girl, whom he befriended at the orphanage. 

My Ramblings

I posted some ramblings under a specific Bottled Passion post here at http://www.point2e.com/2011/12/bottled-passion-tvb2011o.html which contains some spoiler but of course not as much as this review. 

What To Expect

I rarely put the producer’s name in my review, in part because I don’t care, but I decided to put Lee Tim Shing’s name because his name will reveal several things about this series: 

1. It is a family drama/conflict minus the handclapping and Har Yu’s incessant laughs and no Moses Chan (that is Mui Siu Ching’s forte). 

2. It is always serious drama with a bit of lighthearted moments so that you won’t get too stressed watching it. 

3. The main protagonist is always the one with struggling family business who has to battle other people to make sure family stays afloat. 

4. Reminiscent of any Jin Yong series, expect a lot of people in one particular expose scene that is bound to be explosive minus the bombs. 

5. A rather romantic chaste love affair between the two main characters who will almost always be parted longer than they’re together. Some may feel even though the brief reunion is nonetheless a happy one, in the end the way to the relationship is too difficult, too brief and frankly almost always childless. In that regards, Safe Guards is the happiest of his produced series but to me No Regrets was most romantic. 

What Not to Expect

1. Wayne Lai. He is not in here. 

2. The main protagonist and story are neither struggles to keep the family afloat nor a woman’s struggle against injustice and fighting the Japanese. It is a man’s plan for revenge and his search for his one true love.

 3. It is 21 episodes but in my book, this series ended at episode 20. Episode 21 was in Chinese speak “Tor yu,” meaning waste of film. I shall explain more but beware of spoilers. 

Comments

I am glad I avoided all spoilers for this series since I suspected a certain ending, which would be tragic. Although, I expected at the end, a happy childless reunion. In that regards, I was wrong and so be prepared, this is not a happy ending. For me, however the unhappy ending is not the supposed tragic end of a main character, but rather how the writer chose to end that life.

Can I just reveal the spoiler? Because I can’t write this review without discussing the last episode and I can’t discuss the last episode without revealing who the heck died. So if you want spoilers free, best avoid this review from this moment onwards. 

Tung Boon Sin dies in the end. That is supposed to be tragic, only if how he died is well written but it isn’t. To me the most tragic thing about the ending is how ridiculous it was. Imagine: for 20 episodes, 20 glorious exciting episodes, this series can do no wrong. It was engaging, it stopped at that right moment that made me go, “DAMN IT!! Have to wait tomorrow!” I was excited for the next episode, the next, and another. Some characters ended brilliantly; some you knew could have been better. Twenty amazing episodes and then came episode 21. That ruined it all. So in order to enjoy this series, ignore episode 21. It does not exist. It has been sucked into the black hole of “That Episode Did Not Exist” portal. Just pretend episode 20 is the ending. Done. Period. And then you will wanna know why the heck it ended the way it did? I think I know why, but before I reach that point, can I just write something positive about this series. Let me start by explaining why I even watched it in the first place. 

I had nothing to watch except for Ghetto Justice, but this series came before Ghetto Justice. I am neither a fan of Raymond Wong nor Niki Chow and the title deceived me into thinking this is a light hearted romance story. The poster didn’t help, but I knew it was a Lee Tim Shing’s production and frankly like his production, so I switched on. 

Episode 1 was engaging, but I was hooked from episode 2 onwards. I like the story of an anti hero and everything pointed towards that with regards to Tung Boon Sin. I was curious who Milk Candy Girl was, although I should have known better. I suppose what engaged me was the story of Yoyo Chen’s pitiful character and what Tung Boon Sin had to do with her tragic end. Some parts are told in flashbacks, neither lingering nor repetitive and this being a typical Lee Tim Shing story, you’ll get the bottom of things within no time. I absolutely enjoyed the first few episodes that I decided to catch this series as it is broadcast, becoming more and more immersed into the web of lies concocted by Tung Boon Sin and his treatment towards the many women in this series. I am pretty sure viewers will be shocked at what he went through as a child and will generally agree Tung Kwok Hing is the ultimate villain in this series. I am also pretty sure viewers will agree that the seduction scenes between Tung Boon Sin and Ko Yi Kiu is pretty seductive except if you’re not a Raymond Wong fan you will feel there is nothing sexy at what you will see, like myself. One particular scene which was rather memorable was Ko Yi Nga on a swing, swinging herself towards a squatting Tung Boon Sin, as she grabbed him and he pushed her away, grabbed him and he pushed her away and finally she fell on top of him. Again the problem will be if you feel nothing for the actors, that scene would be seductive but not sexy. 

And this is one series that tries very hard to make such seduction scenes sexy. The music for one; every time Ko Yi Kiu appears with Tung Boon Sin, it is that music that connotes a seduction scene. Every single time. Whether it is actually sexy or not is entirely up to you as the viewer. For me, I find it not that sexy. I am never a fan of TVB kissing scenes and here, there is one supposedly passionate kissing scene between Raymond and Elaine and frankly I thought a CPR scene is sexier. But still kudos to the “foreplay” leading up to that scene, how he looked at her, how she looked at him, how he talked to her, put on the flat shoes for her, touching her feet, etc. He is seducing her, she is trying hard not to be seduced. For Ko Yi Nga, it is her doing the seducing, he pretending not to be seduced. 

As for Tsui Sum, that is typical Lee Tim Shing love story; entirely chaste and yet something deeply romantic. They’re mostly apart, standing apart, talking apart, sitting apart and yet there is intimacy in their relationship, a lot of teary eyed stares and in the end culminating in deep embraces and still look chaste. I would say in a typical Lee Tim Shing love story, what is profound is the respect and love between the main couple; kissing, embraces, etc rarely happens because the intimacy comes from the fact that they genuinely love one another. It is what I consider the purest form of love between 2 unrelated people, and none more so than for in the series of No Regrets. The union is always brief, the reunion in this series however is even more short-lived than I expected, and I do believe the ending is of course to illustrate the nature of the character of Tung Boon Sin; he mysteriously appeared in Tsui Sum’s life and in the end he mysteriously disappeared from her life. Doesn’t mean I like it that way though. I was hoping for fewer metaphors. Why does love need to have metaphors anyway? Just bloody give them a happy ending, instead of the metaphors of this life, next life, the life after. At least this isn’t some Korean drama series where dying is as happy as living. No suicide here for the lead characters (well maybe you can consider it suicide but I let you decide), we have very strong female and male characters in here and credit to Lee Tim Shing, his female characters are often stronger than they look and this is what I like about Bottled Passion. For all the betrayal that Tung Boon Sin has chosen to unleash upon Tsui Sum, and she was depressed, she doubted, she questioned, she wondered, but in the end she still sees things with a clear mind and never once did she consider jumping into the river to end it all. She was pushed down, she stood back up again, she got cheated of her land, she found another, her company went bust, she created another, she was cheated of her love and her heart was stolen, she chose to find out what made him do what he did although she disliked him at first, never really hated him. She loved more than she cared to hate and generally she is a strong character that does not wallow in self pity for too long. Even if in this series she plays second fiddle to the main guy that is Tung Boon Sin, her character nevertheless is pivotal in all his later decisions and to her credit, the questions she demanded an answer for are legitimate ones and later she learned to trust her gut instinct and thereon she never once asked him any questions she knew he wouldn’t answer or that she knew he would later give her an adequate answer. You can say she is naive, she is trusting but I feel her entire family is naive, her entire family is trusting but Tsui Sum is above that in the sense she  chose to trust Tung Boon Sin and let him do whatever he needs to do when thereafter he will return to her. There is a promise between them two and she waited for him to fulfill his promise. In that sense this is one very romantic pair, a very old fashioned love story created at first by deceit and in the end liberated by the truth; he told her who he was, he told her what he was doing, for the rest he didn’t tell her, she simply told him she will wait for him. Maybe I am old fashioned, but I really find them to be terribly old fashioned romantic. 

The other characters are memorable as well and I do appreciate that every character in here however small a role plays a significant part that has some meaning in it.

I always have a soft spot for Raymond Cho but I always dislike the weak elder brother character that depends on his sister for survival and saddled by a very demanding noisy bitchy wife. It appears so for the first few episodes but luckily it didn’t go that way. Tsui Ping is a weak man, and he knows it and he highly respects his much smarter younger sister who basically is the head of the family. However there was no jealousy, although pushed by the wife to gain control of the business, the best thing is Tsui Sum doesn’t actually usurp the brother’s position in the family. She remains respectful to him and to her sister in law and as the series progresses, you will see Wan Yau the sister in law isn’t so bad after all. She is that sort that isn’t very educated, sees things in a straightforward way and when it comes to crunch time, she stands by the family, no matter what. Tsui Ping never wavers from his loyalty to his family and he really loves his sister; he treasures her, protects her as best as he could and displayed such brotherly affection for her despite his cowardice in the beginning that in the end you will like Tsui Ping very much. The youngest, which is Tsui Onn is also a nice young man, who was tricked into owing massive amount of money and is involved in Tsui Sum selling the soy sauce factory land to Tung Boon Sin, already a shareholder at that time which ultimately led to Tsui Sum’s heartbreak when he betrayed her by reselling the land to the Ko family and then disappearing. However again Tsui Onn in the worst of time displayed a certain integrity in character; he owned up to what he did to his family, he found a job, he supported the family for a certain period of time. Basically the Tsui family consists of good decent hardworking people and the family trusts one another, protects one another, loves one another. 

Contrast that with the Ko family. Everybody scheming against everybody, primarily the mother Tung Kwok Hing against everyone, even her own daughters. From what was shown, Tung Kwok Hing was from a rich influential family who married Ko Siu Tong presumably of lower birth and with her money and his ability he founded his company and built his fortune. Tung Kwok Hing wants to appear as the supportive wife, so she appeared encouraging towards the husband’s endeavour, including searching for the long lost illegitimate son. But the truth is she will do everything in her power to secure her son’s position. She doesn’t seem to care much for her daughters; they were her pawns in gaining the favour and fortune of her husband. Ko Yi Tai was her primary concern; I assume since he is the only son. One very realistic scene or several realistic scenes involved Ko Yi Tai pushing the more able sister, Ko Yi Kiu to marry her fiance, the sickly Man Hon who was the only son of the police commissioner in town, I think. Anyway very powerful connection there. It is realistic because he would always remind her that being a daughter, she will have no lasting hold on the father’s company since daughters are to be married off. How unfair for Kiu since frankly she is the one running the company for a few years, she is more able than her brother whose only advantage is he is a son. I sort of pitied her; no matter what she does, however well she does, in the end she has no share in the fortune and is doomed to marry a sickly man and probably doomed to a lifetime of widowhood. So in her heart she knows her position and she also knows her mother will make sure of that. Between them two, there is no sincerity in their relationship. Same with Ko Yi Nga who appears to be the baby of the family, everyone dotes on her but in the end it was like a forced sort of relationship. The family is unraveling anyway, from the strict control of the mother, the unfairness of everything so Tung Boon Sin’s appearance is not the reason the family fell apart but you can say he is the cause of it. I find the Ko family fake; fake in appearance, fake in so called professed love and respect for one another. As opposed to the Tsui family who sticks together, the Ko family falls apart at the slightest drama although Tung Kwok Hing tried her best to keep the family together. She just doesn’t realise she is the reason the family was falling apart. A control freak. The only redeeming factor in the Ko family was Dr Yuen Yau Hin, the illegitimate son who valued his relationship with his father above all. Frankly Mr Ko does not deserve such a good son. 

Another more family than the Ko family consisted of 3 people who are not related to one another; that are Uncle Sek who saved Lee Ho’s life and gave him a new identity that is Tung Boon Sin, Tung Boon Sin himself and the younger man he saved many years ago and became his loyal friend, Lo Yat. These 3 stuck together at the worst of time; one helping the other and for me I was very moved by Lo Yat’s loyalty to Boon Sin and Boon Sin’s care for Lo Yat. I find these 2, even if including Uncle Sek to be more genuine as a family than the entire Ko family.

This series illustrates sometimes being related need not mean closeness and sometimes being unrelated can still forge a tie closer than that of blood ties. Maybe I am sentimental but I am moved by the relationship between Tsui Ping and Tsui Sum and Boon Sin and Lo Yat. 

But let’s not move away from the primary romantic love story that is Boon Sin and Tsui Sum. Like I said, I should have known from episode 1 Tsui Sum is the Milk Candy Girl. I knew that about quarter of the series because this series doesn’t seem to want to suggest a 2nd unknown female character. I wished it had. It would have made it more difficult for Boon Sin, to choose between his real love that is Tsui Sum and his long lost love, Milk Candy Girl. But the aim of the series is not a choice between 2 loves but rather a choice between persisting with revenge and giving up. At times I was imploring Boon Sin to give up on revenge; no better revenge than to live a happier life than your enemy and there is Tsui Sum, the ideal of happiness. But I also understand his need for revenge; after all that despicable Mrs Ko did throw an 8 year old defenceless boy into the ravine, nearly drowned him as well. But as I remember, he probably only stayed there for couple of months, so it was just a couple of months of deceit compared to a lifetime of happiness; so why persist on revenge? As this series explains, in the end he persisted because to save Tsui Sum; if he doesn’t destroy his enemy, his enemy will use his beloved to destroy him. And the one enemy he wants to destroy is Mrs Ko. To get to Mrs Ko he needs to use her 2 daughters; between them two, I consider Yi Kiu the innocent one even though when she was a kid she also hit poor Boon Sin. 

Ko Yi Kiu is a rather interesting and somewhat complex character. She epitomizes the idea that she can’t love enough, she can’t hate enough but in a more negative way than Tsui Sum. Boon Sin is quite a bastard when it comes to Yi Kiu; he made her fall in love with him, even when she was very reserved about that, knowing that she will have to throw her future away if she chooses to be with Boon Sin and she didn’t make that choice lightly. One good scene was her running to him with a luggage bag declaring she shall follow him wherever he goes despite going against her mother’s wishes and in the end Boon Sin checked her luggage and in it were files. No clothes, not even a luggage, which meant she didn’t mean what she said, and he will have to make sure the next time she does mean what she says.  I never thought she was capable of anything beyond being in love, but in the end she was so in love she lost the will to live so to speak. Such a selfish self centred woman and yet in the end she could love him enough to kill him. Selfish sort of love. Very dramatic stuff too. I was expecting great things from Yi Kiu though. I expected her to want to revenge by ruining Boon Sin and Tsui Sum business wise, I expected she to run back to Man Hon begging for a 2nd chance so that she can salvage her image before her father and mother. She did none of those which to me were a twist. In the end she just popped 40 pills, whilst dying met with Boon Sin and stabbed him once in the stomach. I don’t think she died in the end; she was on the hospital bed presumably dying. Funny though that she chose to kill herself the same way her jilted fiance did when she left him. 

Ko Yi Nga is an even worse character, which unfortunately was underdeveloped. When things with her got interesting, she had to run away to Shanghai after hurting Tsui Sum and never to return. Thereafter nothing more from her. I was expecting to see a 2nd Mrs Ko in the making, but in the end she was just this nasty little girl; that was how Boon Sin called her anyway. However her ending is interesting; I thought mother died, father had stroke, older brother dead, younger sister tried to kill herself, half brother almost burnt to death, Boon Sin went missing and all these on the newspaper and she just flicked a callous glance and moved on. Quite a vicious girl. She maintained her life as a mistress to a rich man and interestingly, has a lover on the sideline as well. Rather immoral decadent lifestyle for a girl who has neither remorse nor conscience whatsoever. If Ko Yi Nga were to be developed more, she could have been the ultimate villain. Unfortunately her story stopped all of a sudden but to me ended well; that sort of life she had in the end couldn’t have been a good life.

Ko Yi Tai is another fella that is not the worst but one of the worse. He is stupid. Simple. If he is any smarter, he would not have ended up the way he did. The way he treated Yuk Fong (Yoyo Chen), it was despicable. And I thought at first it was Boon Sin! Then the way he treated his sisters, despicable. The way he treated his father, also despicable. The way he treated his wife… well she sorta deserves it. I find her most annoying. The way he treated his servants, oh so despicable. The way to describe Ko Yi Tai is despicable on top of another despicable. I like his ending though, dead with money pouring down onto his body. If he had shown a wee bit of kindness to those in need, he wouldn’t have ended up dead in some god forsaken place. 

Yuen Yau Hin, the illegitimate son is a boring man, boring character, by a boring actor but pivotal to the story. His most interesting moment was when he was bound, fainted and in a burning building because 2 men risked their lives to save him, one of whom my most favourite character in this series. He didn’t die; in the end he took over the business, and a hint of a possible union with Tsui Sum as Tsui Sum asked him when is he getting a girlfriend and he replied “Not yet, but soon”, hinting at Tsui Sum who by that time realized she has to move on in life which she did but no clear answer as to this pair though.

Tung Kwok Hing to me is the ultimate villain. The way she pushed her daughters, the way she protected her son, the way she does things, this woman’s only concern is her son and herself. She seems to be enemies with her own daughters. I wonder did she truly believe half the things she said? Did she ever love her children? And if she did, isn’t her love the wrong sort of love? Was her concern ever genuine? As Boon Sin told her “You fell in the end not because of me but because you never learn to let go” which is true. The last scene before she had a heart attack that ultimately killed her showed her dreaming of Boon Sin as a child running away from her and how she treated him; juxtaposed with Yi Tai struggling with a thief and then falling off the hill and hitting his head on the rocks and died. I was thinking was that to show her guilty conscience? That innately she knew she had done Boon Sin wrong but can’t bring herself to acknowledge it? Or perhaps it is just  a scene to show her nightmare, her fear of Boon Sin now returning to hurt her and her family and that Yi Tai was getting his just end because of the sins of the mother? The deeper meaning or the simpler one? Knowing TVB, probably the simpler one.  But I find this villain the most interesting to watch. 

Ko Siu Tong is just there. He has very little to do towards the end, and not that he could do much since he had a stroke, he couldn’t walk, couldn’t speak. I never thought he was formidable in the first place; his wife was more formidable. 

My most favourite character is the cute Lo Yat. Every single scene except for later parts he is always eating and always a full meal.  At the beginning I thought he would turn traitor due to the actor playing him, at one point I said “A HA!!! TRAITOR!!” but 5 seconds later it was explained why he did what he did. A loyal friend, a brave man, an intelligent guy, I was chanting the mantra “Don’t let Lo Yat be a traitor”, “Don’t let Lo Yat be a traitor”, “Don’t let Lo Yat be a traitor”. Later on when I am satisfied he is not a traitor, my turn to chant “Don’t kill Lo Yat”, “Don’t kill Lo Yat”, “Don’t kill Lo Yat”. At one point I thought “He’s dead! He’s dead!” and I had to wait 1 day to find out he didn’t die. In fact his ending is a happy one. After episode 21, I was like “At least it is not Lo Yat, anyone else I don’t give a damn!”. I like him because I always like the nice sidekick who proves his unwavering loyalty by action. I also like how Boon Sin sees his best friend; secretly apologising for the troubles he has caused him, sending his best friend away as his plans for revenge reaches its final stages and suddenly the best friend appears, refusing to leave. I quite nearly cheered. And at that point I was as emotionally vested in this series as was Lo Yat with his best friend in the world. My only complaint with this relationship is how Lo Yat addresses Boon Sin; Mr Tung. A bit too formal for such an informal relationship but I suppose he only does so in front of strangers. I never paid enough attention to hear whether he calls Boon Sin as Boon Sin in private. 

Which is why I suppose I like this series; it is littered with many characters, each interestingly is given some ample time to develop, and not just any walk on ke-le-fes sort of role. Most often the main leading characters have little to say, it is everyone surrounding them that talks a lot, some way too much. You see their personalities and in some ways the dialogue is interesting without being overbearing. It would be too simplistic to say this series is simple; the contents are simple; the dialogue is same old. Yes it has all the hallmarks of a Lee Tim Shing series, but thankfully without the Mui Siu Ching over cheeriness or over gloominess. It has the right balance to make you like or dislike or hate a certain character. Not all characters are perfect though; even Tsui Sum can be annoying at times. I love to compare Tsui Sum to that of Ruoxi from Bu Bu Jing Xin aka (urgghhhh) Scarlett Heart. The latter says to herself that she can’t hate enough, she can’t love enough and so tortured herself and those she loved and those who loved her endlessly with her indecisiveness whether to follow her heart or follow her conscience. The former is someone who decides on whether that someone she loves is a good person or a bad person and if she believes him to be a good person, she will stand by him no matter what he does, and that includes cheating her family land. Of course you can say Boon Sin and the 4th Prince are in different circumstances but the point here is the reaction of the women they love; in that sense I like Tsui Sum’s more straightforward view of love; you stand by your man no matter what. That of course I must stress Boon Sin ain’t a bad guy, he is just exacting revenge for what he suffered at the hands of Mrs Ko that is Tung Kwok Hing. His body has scars to prove what he went through and basically Tung Kwok Hing is such a nasty woman you can’t help but agree with what he was planning to do to her, that is to destroy her family and thus destroy her, even if it includes walking all over the 2 daughters. And just so you know, anyone who watches Bu Bu Jing Xin will argue either for or against the 4th prince, and one major event that divided fans was the steaming of a well liked character, Yu Tan. I am one who agrees he should not only steam her, but kill off 9 steps of her family line for what she did was inexcusable. And so frankly I am not against what Boon Sin did to Yi Nga and Yi Kiu. A pity that he didn’t do anything exactly to that bastard that is Yi Tai because he is one nasty piece of work for the things he said, the things he did and the one woman who died because of him and that is Fong played by Yoyo Chen, a very naive but in the end pitiful character. In fact, it was this character that made me suspect Boon Sin is a villain since this series in the beginning loves to tell a story by first showing the present and then explaining everything through flashback and it was in flashback you know of Boon Sin’s motive. 

I don’t have any particular love for the flashback mode of storytelling. I felt impatient and I thought how much flashback to tell a story. But some are told effectively; Lo Yat’s past, Boon Sin as Lee Ho and his relationship with Milk Candy Girl, how he was thrown into the river by Mrs Ko. What is missing of course how the heck he survived THAT. Not told at all. And I must add one scene is a direct copy from Kung Fu Hustle but not that I am complaining; it was rather fitting even if a bit embarrassing to watch. 

But generally the storytelling in this series is well paced and it stops at the right climax; making you want to know more and can’t wait for the next episode. I had the good fortune of watching with very little spoilers found online so the story was kept exciting and intriguing for the most part. But even if you know the ending, it doesn’t matter; you can enjoy the story nonetheless for the process of it even if I do agree knowing the ending will spoil the mood. But seriously, if you are an avid fan of Lee Tim Shing series, you would already know even if this couple ends happily, it would be a very short happy ending. And in true Lee Tim Shing fashion, when Tsui Sum and Boon Sin whispered sweet nothings to each other in episode 20, I knew episode 21 will be a death sentence for either one of them. And with the exception of Safe Guards, every of his series almost always end with the woman surviving and the man dying. So I expected nothing less for Bottled Passion, but at least I said to the TV “Let them have children!!!!”. Ahhh, cruelly, no children, and cruelly, not even anything except for a very chaste kiss. 

And now the ending. Episode 21. The one single episode that quite nearly destroyed the entire series, and makes me yell out “OI! WHAT THE HELL IS  GOING ON MR TIM GOR GOR?!?!” 

And to know why I said what I said, you need to know the ending. Spoilers ahead. 

Boon Sin got stabbed by Yi Kiu who herself took 40 sleeping pills or whatever pills she took. He rushed out, knife deeply lodged into his stomach, and dripping with blood and one supposedly dying at any minute. But he didn’t die, not yet. He met no less than 2 people; one a passerby whom he urged to go save Yi Kiu first. And then he staggered away and fell to the floor and met with Dr Yuen. When Dr Yuen returned with help, he disappeared and we see him struggling to walk away from Guangzhou, do remember the knife still in his stomach and from dead at night with NO ONE on the streets to morning light as he struggled to get into a boat, even managed to get the boat to float to middle of sea or lake or whatever and then as he laid flat on his back looking up at the sky, again the knife still in his stomach he finally died, one would assume from major blood loss. Because no way he can die of the knife wound if he can still walk around Guangzhou for at least no less than 6 or 7 hours. 

And why I wonder for that 6 or 7 hours did he not crawl to the hospital?!?!?! Why did he chose to die? Why didn’t he save himself when at least 2 people could have saved him? Why? 

One theory fans say is because he didn’t want to die in the hospital and then have Yi Kiu charged with murder, since if there is no body, there can not be murder, at least back then. I can debunk that. Why? Because if he had gone to the hospital within 2 hours or so, he needn’t die at all and he can lie about how he got stabbed, so Yi Kiu can get away with it. 

Another theory fans say is he didn’t want Tsui Sum to know he died, as in actually died, so as not to crush her hope. I can debunk that and I can only say “Because if he had gone to the hospital within 2 hours or so, he needn’t die at all and he can” then be happily ever after with Tsui Sum. 

Some more theory fans say is to show the mysteriousness of his character. Since he appeared out of nowhere and caused quite a scandal with no less than 4 women (try figure which one!), the fact that he disappeared so mysteriously is only apt. You know, like a magician and the tricks Boon Sin love to pull sort of nonsense. Yes, nonsense. This is not some mystery series; we know where he comes from, so why the need to make him just die the way he did? 

A more credible theory is that because of a conversation he had with Tsui Sum where Tsui Sum said, “You’re not Lee Ho anymore, and I am not Milk Candy Girl. That is our past life. We had a chance back then, now we are given a second chance at our present life; you’re now Tung Boon Sin and I am Tsui Sum.” 

So in the end Tsui Sum said to herself their destiny for this life is over, she will wait for him for the next life.

Fans argue a sequel is a must to show just that and my argument is when did this series turn to supernatural element?! He is DEAD! DEAD! DEAD! This is no Laughing Gor resurrection again and again and again and again. DEAD! MATI! SI LIAO! What more can be more obvious than a man stabbed in the stomach crawling half of Guangzhou and onto a boat for more than half a night and then DIE? Of course he died looking into the sky but still, he died! 

My theory at this ending is 4 fold: 

1. To shock – I was shocked, at the stupidity of it

2. To lend credibility to what Tsui Sum said about past present life except poor Tsui Sum, didn’t she realise the past and present life she spoke of is of the same person in the same life? Anyone has the heart to tell poor Tsui Sum that it is THE END?

3. To increase the level of mysteriousness of Boon Sin’s appearance and disappearance, even if Tsui Sum had to wait 6 long years to know he is deader than the deadest dead. But I wonder, why the mystery when in the end the whole mystery is debunked when Dr Yuen told us what he saw and later we are shown how Boon Sin died? If you want mystery, leave it at what Dr Yuen said; he saw, he turned, Boon Sin disappeared. The end. Why bother explaining until the intestines?

4. My choice of Tim Gor Gor sudden madness at this ending, that is to create a sad sad ending. My reaction is to laugh and laugh and laugh. It was stupid. Entire episode 21 was flashback, more flashback and then he died and then we find out how where when why. And I laughed some more. For me episode 21 does not exist. It ended with episode 20, Tsui Sum and  Boon Sin, happily ever after. Episode 21 was like that relative you never want to see suddenly showing up at your doorstep with a major shocking revelation and then disappeared and you are left wondering who the heck was that and what the hell just happened. A certain sense of anti climax. 

Exactly my reaction to episode 21. Take my advice; ignore episode 21 exists. There is nothing poetic with that sort of stupid ending. I would rather Yi Kiu stabbed him, he rushed to somewhere and die from blood loss instead of crawling here, there, like a scenic tour of Guangzhou before his death. 

And of course ignore the inconsistencies; one part Dr Yuen was supposed to have left the city with his father, then suddenly he is still there. Or the ever changing outer coat of  Tsui Sum in a single scene. Leave the technicalities aside and frankly the story is pretty solid in this series. 

And that is why I love this series. The story and the storytelling; it doesn’t meander, it doesn’t go round and round, it doesn’t leave any guess work, it is straightforward good old storytelling, except for the stupid episode 21. 

I must mention one thing that I didn’t see in TVB for a very long time and in here I see more of it, and that is the act of smoking. In here, it is used to show the loss of innocence and the craftiness of Yi Nga and then it is used to show the stylish and adult way of Boon Sin. You must watch how Raymond Wong lighted his first cigarette in this series; with such force and such style, I quite almost celebrated the return of smoking in a TV series. 

Performances wise, I was very impressed with a few of them and lament the fact that by next year this series and the wonderful performances will be forgotten, if the episode 21 has yet to kill off the series’ credibility. 

The children who played Tong Tong and Lee Ho. Cute children, can act, and I dare say Tong Tong’s performance of a limping leg is more consistent than Niki Chow’s performance of a limping leg. 

Raymond Wong Ho Yin portrayed the complexities and the sufferings of Tung Boon Sin very well. I like particularly those scenes where he silently cried, whilst eating the soy sauce meal. If you’re Tsui Sum indeed you will wonder what is bothering this man, why he is as such. He did the mysterious Tung Boon Sin even better; and like a hurricane he swept into the lives of the Ko females, seduced them and toyed with their hearts. It is the gentle caring Boon Sin that I find convincing as well as the angry shouting Boon Sin, the way he shouted at Tsui Sum, scolded her, all for her own good. But it is the seducer Boon Sin which I find hard to believe. Raymond Wong is a good looking guy but he is hardly sexy. When he removed his clothes, internet wrote of his “amazing body” but I was busy looking at the scars. He had spray tanned himself for sure but I still find his pale and sickly looking. Half the time I thought Boon Sin just emerged from a long illness or is about to be really ill. That being said, what I love about Raymond Wong himself is he can act, no doubt but he found his perfect niche in characters from this series’ era because the way he speaks, he is very clear in his pronunciation and yet there is a slight cute accent but then accent or no accent, the way he speaks, one word at a time, makes me think of him as an honest guy. There is something very old fashioned about him and that is what I like most about him. Anyway even with episode 21 he gave an excellent performance although the kissing and seduction scenes were merely adequate but not enough. Maybe in a more sexier actor, Tung Boon Sin could have been a more animalistic sort of guy and with a title like Bottled Passion, I would expect Boon Sin to be someone oozing with sex appeal, and not just good old fashioned good looking. 

Raymond Cho, the other Raymond in this series gave one of his best performance in his career. His Tsui Ping is cowardly, he is at times you may think useless but Raymond Cho gave Tsui Ping a certain sense of honesty and goodness that you can’t help but like the earnest Tsui Ping. I love how his character progressed to be stronger and stronger for the sake of his sister and how he defended her in front of Boon Sin or his family in front of the Kos. 

Claire Yiu impressed me with her guest performance in Ghetto Justice and I suppose I haven’t seen much of her because I was very impressed with her performance as Wan Yau, the nosy talkative but in the end harmless sister in law. My only problem with her is her dialogue is too much at times and also her pregnancy seems to be slow mo, as if she was carrying Ne Zha instead of a normal human baby because she is pregnant for the entire series which mean whatever happened to Tsui Sum and Boon Sin, it can not be more than 1 year less.

Joel Chan was at first quite impressive as the disgusting Yi Tai. He seems to make a career out of being disgusting. But after a while, I don’t know,  I laughed very hard when he was arguing with Tracy Ip who plays his rather irritating wife and he was shouting so much his voice broke in mid shout, like it went to falsetto for a moment. It was very funny, reminds me of Kevin Cheng shouting until his voice hoarse in I believe Last Man Standing or something like that. But it was a credible performance.

Tracy Ip as Bak Wai the wife is a bit too stressed for my taste. Her every scene she seems to look stressed and delivered her lines like she is very stressed which she is. But I don’t even like her Bak Wai in the first place. I find her rather dumb and of course how interesting she should think of punishing her philandering husband by sleeping with a homeless dirty guy and got pregnant because of that.

Samuel Kwok was a miscast. I didn’t find his Mr Ko scary or authoritative.

Rebecca Chan as Tung Kwok Hing deserves an award. First of, I find her very beautiful in the way she dressed and her hair and make up. Her Mrs Ko is enigmatic and scary as well as insufferable and a control freak. She gave a whole lot of layers to her Mrs Ko and I find her character and her performance fascinating. I also like her ending; a rather mundane death you know for such a cruel highly strung person.

I still remember Elaine Yiu’s performance in Safe Guards, I believe her first? Anyway she was god awful in there but Safe Guards will always be one of my top 5 favourite series of all time despite her god awful performance. In  here, she has improved so much I could hardly recognise that’s her. She plays the suffering and controlled Yi Kiu very well, and even her look of disbelief that Boon Sin loved her so was well done. However the seduction scenes, kissing scenes and her act of stabbing Boon Sin were not believable. But I suppose even a very strong career minded selfish woman such as Yi Kiu could fall deeply in love, enough to want to kill herself for him but also reveal her selfishness by stabbing him as well. There is nothing selfless about Ko Yi Kiu. Anyway a fantastic performance by Elaine Yiu and I believe one of best.

I do not know who is Katy Kung, I just remember her from her guest appearance in Ghetto Justice but in here she has a substantial role until suddenly disappearing and then reemerging in the end with a rather fitting ending for such a selfish cruel girl. First of, I don’t find her pretty. In fact I find Katy very weird looking; her nose, her eyes, her face, everything. I don’t find her remotely pretty at all. But that doesn’t mean she can’t act. I find her raw, but in her rawness there is a certain I suppose earnestness in the way she acted. I don’t find her pretentious nor acting like she is acting. She has potential but still a long way to go. At least she doesn’t have the habit of looking at the camera unconsciously. And she does have a difficult role to do; the amount of scheming, conniving, seducing she had to do, I will say she did very well for someone I believe as inexperienced as her. 

I have no comment on Vin Choi except to say he has that perpetual look of a worrier. But he is rather good looking and tall and fair and a good face for such a period as depicted in this series. A pity the acting itself is a bit debatable. 

Eric Li as Lo Yat is my most favourite performance in here, not because he was the best but because I like Lo Yat the best. Eric Li has the face of a villain, and he has acted in many villainous role, too many to count. To my memory I can’t remember him as the good guy so when I saw his face in here, I predicted he will betray Boon Sin. He didn’t. He in fact remained loyal which made me like him more. Who knew Eric Li could he cute with a simple bowl of noodles in his hands? And he ate a lot. He was always eating which added to the casualness of his character. It just shows a well written character can turn an actor into any personality the writing dictates; I do think of this casting as against type. Lo Yat still looks like a traitor which I suppose why Eric Li was casted in this role; to confuse us all. Fantastic performance though. 

Everybody else did well, and I have no comment. 

Now… Niki Chow, fans love her will love her, fans dislike her will dislike her. I am one of those who dislike her because I think she is not just a poor actress, she is a bad actress. She is not the worst actress. I wouldn’t even say she is one dimensional with a singular feature at any one time. She can cry, she can laugh, she can praise, etc but she doesn’t do anything much to any particular character she is portraying because each expression is rather… amateur. She didn’t interprete the role much; she just I suppose read script, see role, act. I find no depth in her performance. And she was supposed to look at our hero with I suppose bottled passion (ALL THE PUN INTENDED) but she looks… interested. When I read this character was written specially for her as her comeback series to TVB, frankly I didn’t expect much. She looks better now, fuller face, fuller body, she is prettier than she was before, as maturity gave her face a sense of gravitas as an actress. Acting wise, I admit she improved. But her improvement is minimal. I can imagine someone else as Tsui Sum; she didn’t own this character but she went along with it. She did better in later scenes as she cries but throughout every time she utters a line from the script, it felt like “pui ging”; meaning someone reading her lines. I find the way she speaks too lazy, her expression between happy and pained. She did not give Tsui Sum depth, when in a better actress’ hands, this character would be more complex than Niki Chow presented. I do find her performance at times bland, but her best moment is when she has to be angry or tough, there is a little personality showing through but most of the time, it is to me a “just enough” performance; just enough to make do; just enough not to destroy the series. Just “just enough”.  At some point I did feel her performance should have derailed this series’ engaging storytelling but it didn’t not because she was amazing but because thanks to the story and the storytelling. She is almost always never alone in a scene; she is almost always surrounded by veterans who had more lines to utter, so frankly sometimes your attention will be shifted to other people. If you just sit down and focus on her, ignore everyone else and I can’t imagine you can ever say she was a fantastic actress. To me she was a “just enough” actress. And I long for more than “just enough” although her “just enough” performance did not in anyway kill this series. The ending did, if ever there was any such element. However I must add I thought she was very beautiful in the last scene, her hair and her make up was just right. 

Verdict

I know many fans will think “Aiyah! Same old! Same old!” True. But good and trusted formula should never be dismissed as same old, same old. As long as it is a good story well told, why not? More so it has some of the best performances of 2011, memorable characters and notwithstanding the stupid ending, it is by itself one of the best if not the best TVB series of 2011. If you wish for something different and you think I want more, let me assure you this is not the run of the mill series. It has every element; love, hate, revenge, forgiveness, fate, destiny, everything! And you know what I love most about Lee Tim Shing series apart from the whole family drama and the sometimes inspiring dialogue? The love story. In every one of his series, his leading characters are often involved in chaste but deep love and respect for one another, Bottled Passion is no different. I find Tsui Sum and Boon Sin very romantic as a pair; the things they do for one another, the things they sacrifice and the things they utter, however forced in this series (the part about past present life), they’re still in essence depicting a good old fashioned love story. Kissing is not expected; embrace maybe. But the longing, the stares, the shy meeting of the eyes or the passion in the form of love turning to hate turning to love back to respect and in the end the all encompassing trust is in itself one of those rare sort of love relationship seen in TVB series. They’re so chaste at times you wish for that passionate embrace, not just grateful embrace, but that all passionate roll on the grass embrace. There is more passionate display in this series than in many of his previous productions but still all very chaste. I still find his other productions’ heroines and heroes more passionate without touching, more romantic without being physical but Tsui Sum and Tung Boon Sin are pretty close in being die hard romantics.

And that is why I really like this series. 

Good old fashioned story well told in good old fashioned way supplemented by good old fashioned performances depicted good old fashioned characters, even the villains seem good old fashioned with a love story which is touching and … good old fashioned. 

Which basically means it is entertaining, emotionally affecting, generally well acted, memorable characters with memorable lines, with climatic ending scenes in almost every episode leaving you wanting more, almost well directed and somewhat well written (as I shall remember bitterly how the last episode nearly pulled down this series and buried it deep with it in the deep dark Pacific ocean and shall become a stuff of legend, like Atlantis except I shall never ever want to find it). 

I highly recommend this to anyone who wants to watch .. what I call a good story well told. 

Just ignore episode 21. Chant this with me, “It does not exist; it does not exist; it does not exist!”

 

This review was written by Funn Lim, a Contributing Writer at JayneStars.com. The review was first posted at Point2e.com.

79 comments to Review: Bottled Passion (by Funn)

  1. EkinFan says:

    since when did funn start writing articles?

    Login or Register before you can reply to EkinFan
    • jayne replied:

      Ekinfan,
      If you enjoy Funn’s writing, she also wrote Episodic Thoughts for “Ghetto Justice”:
      http://www.jaynestars.com/news/episodic-thoughts-ghetto-justice-episode-1/

      Login or Register before you can reply to jayne
    • Kidd replied:

      Funn has written movie, series and book reviews for many years already. Just that in the past, she posted in on her own site.

      You can read her other review in her blog
      http://www.point2e.com/

      For movies review, she has also uploaded some to spcnet.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Kidd
    • HeTieShou replied:

      Yea, Funn has written many really long and detaile reviews for years already. I really enjoy reading them, but get lazy at times since they can get really long winded… However, they are really detailed and are a great read before you want to watch any movie or series.

      Login or Register before you can reply to HeTieShou
      • Funn Lim replied:

        I can be quite long winded huh? Been trying hard to be brief but in the end never succeed. So there are more series I wanted to write for, formulated the entire thing in my head and ended up not writing at all because it was too long. I am getting rusty.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Funn Lim
      • HeTieShou replied:

        Funn,
        I actually appreciate your long reviews so please keep on writing them. I am actually more disappointed at those really short and brief ones that really don’t say much since it showed that the reviewer/writer was just plain lazy… If they were that lazy, I question why they even bothered to write a review at all…

        Login or Register before you can reply to HeTieShou
  2. Larry 3 says:

    How the hell I can ignore episode 21 that I watch it bunch of times ????? 🙂

    Login or Register before you can reply to Larry 3
    • Larry 3 replied:

      Funn, I disagree on Niki Chow, I think she blew my expectations. She did really good on her role. Yes, I was doubting on her acting experiences in the past TVB series that may affect Bottled Passion. It maybe Lee Tim Sing or other acting coach pressure her to act more fluently in the role of Tsui Sum. Could have eased the crying a little back in some episodes. Certainly, this is really boost for Niki’s acting career.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Larry 3
      • Larry 3 replied:

        Samuel Kwok a miscast? really?. Would it be better to get Lawrence Ng Wai Kwok (伍衛國) to played this type of the role?

        Login or Register before you can reply to Larry 3
      • Larry 3 replied:

        Katy Kung is a newbie, very young actress. Has the potential. Too bad that role she could have dress more seductive clothes and more viewers can watch it!

        Login or Register before you can reply to Larry 3
      • Larry 3 replied:

        This series need more smoking scenes at that time of the era. Pity TVB.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Larry 3
      • claimine replied:

        I agree with Funn’s appraisals on the cast. Niki’s performance, to me, was the weakest among the cast members (BP is my 1st time watching her series); Raymond Wong did really well but yeah still sported a sickly pallor, and a tragic hero’s demeanor. Elaine’s performance was very impressive; thoroughly enjoyed watching magpie Claire’s and villain looking Eric’s performances. Have always like Raymond Cho’s solid acting,and Katy Kung looks off with her too high and pinched nose. But I enjoyed Rebecca’s performance most of all definitely deserving an award for her spot on portrayal. And Samuel Kwok was just there.

        And yeah, same old,same old story. Actually with all due respect to Tim shuk, I find his latter series after Safeguards and Rosy Business quite same old same old.

        And totally my own opinion, I despise a man who deliberately uses a woman’s affection/love for ulterior gains. Men like TBS are too scary for me whereby their thinking and actions are so completely driven by extreme emotions that overwhelmed his conscience. Attacking the weak and the innocents are deplorable cowardly acts, never mind dishonorable. But of course, TBS is no honorable man. TBS can wreak vengeance by taking over the family business through devious means.

        Login or Register before you can reply to claimine
      • HeTieShou replied:

        I have not seen this series yet but have heard that Niki’s performance isn’t that bad. But hey, I guess that is how actors and actress survive in the circle since their acting skills are subjectives. Some may love them while others will hate them….

        Login or Register before you can reply to HeTieShou
      • Vivien replied:

        Yah agreed this is a boost in Niki’s acting career

        Login or Register before you can reply to Vivien
    • Larry 3 replied:

      For me this series has three major problems:

      1. The episode 20 B/ 21 ending suck. Redo the ending, TVB!
      2. The theme song is overused in this series, would have been great to get a sub theme song.
      3. Airing this series so freaken late in December. Should have been airing in October on “Super Ship” timeslot. A DUMB decision by TVB. This series could have been featured TVB’s 44 anniversary award show THAT could brought in lots of awards.

      —————————————
      Unfortunately, this is not my favorite TVB series in 2011. That would be Ghetto Justice. That should have set the standard of TVB series.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Larry 3
      • HeTieShou replied:

        @Larry 3,
        Is the ending truly that bad?? If you like complete endings like my mom does, then I think that may be why you hate the ending in this series. My mom likes complete endings where everything is resolved and there are no openings… Just like how she enjoyed series like Looking Back in Anger and The Four, she hated the ending and how open they were.

        Login or Register before you can reply to HeTieShou
    • Funn Lim replied:

      IGNORE IT! I mean watch but ignore. But why you watch so many times?!?!

      Samuel Kwok is a miscast. He doesn’t have that well.. maybe for this role that is not well written and so sorta lacking authority. Lawrence Ng? No no also no. Elliot Ngok has my vote. BUT Samuel Kwok was wonderful in Safe Guards though, but his role in Safe Guards is a nice guy.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Funn Lim
  3. Larry 3 says:

    ” Basically, Tung Boon Sin does not let Dr Yuen take him to the hospital because he already knows that he wouldn’t be able to survive and doesn’t want Tsui Sum to watch him die. In the end, he chooses to go off and die by himself because he wants to leave hope for Tsui Sum that there are miracles in this world. By still holding onto the possibility that Tung Boon Sin might have survived and may still return someday, this keeps her going and doesn’t make situation completely hopeless. So even in death, Tung Boon Sin was still looking out for Ngau Nai Tong (Milk Candy). ”

    —- http://asianfanatics.net/forum/topic/764183-ending/page__view__findpost__p__7033721

    Login or Register before you can reply to Larry 3
    • Larry 3 replied:

      That ending still sucks. Too draggy.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Larry 3
      • HeTieShou replied:

        I heard that the ending is open which really reminds me of the ending in Looking Back in Anger…

        Login or Register before you can reply to HeTieShou
      • Funn Lim replied:

        Not open. He died. Ending.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Funn Lim
      • HeTieShou replied:

        Oh really?? But then, Nicki did know that right?? Therefore, I thought it was still open since NIcki was still wondering if he died or not. I guess it it different from Looking Back in Anger since in that case, even us viewers did not know if Carina died or not…

        Login or Register before you can reply to HeTieShou
    • AC replied:

      This is so stupid! Why give her false hope so that she’ll never move on for the rest of her life? This was such a bad ending.

      Login or Register before you can reply to AC
    • Funn Lim replied:

      I disagree with this analysis. If this is the reasoning, then it is cruel to let a woman wait in vain for the rest of her life. At least Dr Yuen had the decency to tell her, SIX YEARS LATER for her to move on. I feel the ending was written abruptly and I suspect pressured by executives at TVB for a more dramatic end.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Funn Lim
      • llwy12 replied:

        Interestingly enough, I disagreed with the analysis as well (even though I was the one who posted it on AF after reading it on Weibo…lol).

        My interpretation of the ending goes something like this: when Boon Sin got stabbed and told that guy in the street to go save Elaine, he left because he wanted to go see Ngau Nai Tong (which explains why he said “Ngau Nai Tong is waiting for me at home”) — I truly believe that at that time, he was not thinking about whether he was going to die or not, he just wanted to go see the woman he loved. So in that sense, he WAS making an effort to go see her….but of course, due to his injury and the pain, he wouldn’t be able to walk properly, hence staggering through the streets….unfortunately, because he was bleeding so much from his wound, he didn’t make it very far and probably fainted (remember that when Dr Yuen found him, it was already night time and Boon Seen was just lying there — who knows how long he had been there). The moment that Dr Yuen found Boon Seen was probably the moment he realized that he was not going to survive, so that’s when he decides that he doesn’t want Tsui Sum to go through the pain of seeing him die in front of her eyes — so after Dr Yuen leaves to go call a car, Boon Sin leaves to go die on his own. As for the miracles thing, I actually think that was a reference to what Tsui Sum found in the letter — that Boon Sin wanted to save the miracles for her (being able to have her leg healed)….so he would rather sacrifice the chance of himself being saved if it meant she could be healed….

        I still think the staggering through the street thing was unnecessary (and like people have said, the fact that there was no one in the street didn’t make sense), but based on the events that unfolded, the above is the only way I could think of to explain it (and still have it make sense)….

        Login or Register before you can reply to llwy12
      • AC replied:

        I don’t think it was pressured by TVB execs. I think it’s more Lee Tim Sing’s style. Have you ever watched Sweetness in the Salt? To me, it’s better than Bottled Passion but it has the same problems in that it dragged out too long at the end and had a stupid ending.

        Login or Register before you can reply to AC
    • penny4urthoughts replied:

      I think that is probably the intent so I do agree with your point. There was a scene where Tsui Sum went back to his home and found the box of letters he has been writing to Milk Candy Girl. One of the letters said that Li Ho has been given all the luck and that if there is a next time, he asks the heavens to give the luck to Milk Candy Girl. The 6 years later scene did say her leg was all fixed up and healed.

      The biggest complaint is with the exectuion. It’s just not believable. The fact that he had the energy to stagger around the empty streets of a highly populated city trying to get to Tsui Sum then changed his mind and headed towards the pier and happend to find a lonely boat he can pull towards the dock and hull himself onto. Please remember, this is a guy who has all the will power to live for revenge and for his Milk Candy Girl, proven by many deep scars all over his body. This is why I too, want to erase episode from my memory because it makes no sense!

      Login or Register before you can reply to penny4urthoughts
  4. Jack says:

    BP is not the best TVB series I’ve ever seen. I reserve that space for Blood of Good and Evil. But BP was one of the few dramas produced in the last 10 years that I’ve found entertaining. I always looked forward to see Raymond Wong, Eric Li and Elaine Yiu. Niki Chow didn’t kill my enjoyment for the series but I agree, I wish she could have done more with her role. Raymond has gotten better in his acting since he first made his debut. The type of role he had reminded me of Deric Wan’s old roles. Not the same though but Raymond certainly has his own distinctive style.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Jack
    • Vivien replied:

      Raymond is more handsome than Deric wan.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Vivien
      • Jack replied:

        I don’t know if he’s more handsome but then again, I never really thought about their looks. But Deric was much younger than Raymond Wong, here, when he became famous and he’s more boyish as well.

        But I think it can be agreed upon that Deric really nails it when it comes to playing the villian. He makes his performances very memorable (and provoking).

        Login or Register before you can reply to Jack
      • HeTieShou replied:

        It is more than looks, but I must say that acting wise, Deric Wan is a great actor and really nailed his villian roles(especially in Looking Back In Anger). We can all see how memorable he is in many of his roles. Raymond is good in his own right as well…. An actor needs more than just looks, they need talent, charm and many other things too… If you just want to go for looks, then why not just be a model??

        Login or Register before you can reply to HeTieShou
    • llwy12 replied:

      LOL…same here! BOGAE will always be the best series ever in my heart…but BP is definitely one of the best series of the decade for me.

      I also agree that it’s unfair to compare Deric and Raymond because they’re at different levels and both have different styles — but I do agree that the role is ‘reminiscent’ of Deric’s roles.

      Login or Register before you can reply to llwy12
      • lol replied:

        Raymond at least is a better choice rather than Moses or Steven. Moses was the second choice and he will be lacking in the romance and looks. Thanks to Tim Sir for not casting Steven too. since his acting is repetitive formula and he was lacking in 7DIL

        Login or Register before you can reply to lol
      • josie replied:

        Moses would lack in the romance but not the looks. Steven unfortunately, would lack both.

        Login or Register before you can reply to josie
  5. Jack says:

    Another thing to add: I loved the theme song and her sweet voice. I just wished the series could have not overplayed it and got a sub theme as well.

    I watched this series with some expectation at Rebecca’s character would have caught early on to Raymond’s character was doing. And that there would be more conflict and such. But I suppose that her character was too busy to have looked into it throughly. Her mundane death was fitting.

    Claire’s character was annoying but I actually didn’t mind her that much for some reason. But the pregnancy? Even if she didn’t give birth, she should be at least confined to bed or something. Her stomach kept distracting me towards the end.

    The ending was ridiculous. LOL.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Jack
    • Larry 3 replied:

      Yeah, 1 song is really overplayed…. would have use a piano or guitar version….maybe add a sub theme just to balance the drama.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Larry 3
  6. Veejay says:

    I was thinking since Rebecca can act such superb villain in BP, maybe she can act as the Empress Dowager Ci’xi since her performance as villain is so convincing.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Veejay
    • HeTieShou replied:

      Rebecca is a great actress and an experienced one as well…I have enjoyed all of her performances. She already played WuZeTian so it would be great if you can play Dowager CiXi….

      Login or Register before you can reply to HeTieShou
      • Veejay replied:

        Compare Rebecca with Michelle Yim, I think Rebecca is more convincing as villain than Michelle due to her intense killing eyes lol plus her evil smirk.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Veejay
      • Magic replied:

        I agree with both of you! She’s a great actress indeed. I quite liked her in WAB as well! 😀

        Login or Register before you can reply to Magic
    • Funn Lim replied:

      I think she could be Cixi although Michelle is more suitable physically wise.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Funn Lim
  7. jdfkjshlfa says:

    I like Elaine Yiu & Raymond Wong’s fake relationship, it’s much more interesting & fun

    Login or Register before you can reply to jdfkjshlfa
  8. Vivien says:

    I think 180 degrees different than Funn. Niki is fresh and her emotional grip are done well. I can’t see any of other faces in TVB fadan roster taking over Niki as Tsui Sum. Her crying is not forced or fake.

    Raymond Wong needless to say is superb in his role and crying and the chemistry between Niki and Raymond are superb and tragic too

    Login or Register before you can reply to Vivien
    • Liam replied:

      I agreed with you.
      Niki had had delivered a good portrayal.
      Funn, check with Tim Gor.
      He wanted Tsum Sum to be the quietly nice calm gal who takes everytning in her own stride.
      It doesn’t have to be stereotyped overhyped acting all the time as long as the audience is being engaged!
      Frankly speaking. I am bored with those old school acting

      Login or Register before you can reply to Liam
      • Funn Lim replied:

        If wooden acting is the new quiet nice calm sort of acting then yes Niki nailed it. But I never thought being wooden is a good performance.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Funn Lim
      • Vivien replied:

        Funn are you saying you prefer the not wooden = exaggerated acting that Myolie and Tavia always apply? Or Linda when she has to cry or act cute.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Vivien
      • Funn Lim replied:

        What makes you think not wooden means exaggerated expressions? Those are overacting. There is something called the good acting between wooden and overacting. And I am a Linda Chung fan, more so after L-escargot. Such a delight to watch. Yes her voice is sorta whiny but she didn’t act cute; she is naturally cute and that girl has some serious acting chops.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Funn Lim
      • Vivien replied:

        Linda in L Escargot is a typical Linda doing her typical TVB acting and I dont see anything impressive. I found Sonija improving and pretty for her age without heavy makeup. Ocar’s wife Mandy is the highlight so far I watched. That’s a girl with acting chop. Linda lost to this girl

        Login or Register before you can reply to Vivien
      • Veejay replied:

        U wanna see wooden acting? go see Ron Ng, he’s very wooden in his previous acting and still now.

        i’ve never seen Myolie’s acting exeggerating honestly, I think she’s quite cute and funny, good material for comedy series.

        LInda is cute and can really act.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Veejay
      • Vivien replied:

        Myolie is fine in Ghetto which I feel mirrors her real strong career woman personality but in comedy and serious drama her expressions can be too dramatic. Tavia obviously overact to death in MOL.and BTROC.

        Niki is not wooden. She is subtle

        Login or Register before you can reply to Vivien
      • Kidd replied:

        Timothy Cheng’s acting in ‘Where the Legend Begin’ is subtle. Nikki’s acting is not subtle, just lacking.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Kidd
      • Funn Lim replied:

        I like Mandy in L’escargot but I find her acting deliberate at times with the way she said her lines. She is getting there with being natural and flow of her words but not yet. Sonija has improved tremendously and even then I see the old Sonija sometimes. Linda I feel is not given due credit sometimes. If that is the typical her with typical performance, then I applaud her. Move away from the typical this and that, and just look at her performance. Can she act? Yes of course. Did she look deliberate and calculative in her movements? No. I find she has natural grace and a flow to the way she moves and utters her line. Because of that I find her a very good actress. Not yet excellent but hopefully she won’t be like Myolie who lost herself and is trying hard to find her way back.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Funn Lim
      • HeTieShou replied:

        Well once again, acting is subjective and you really hate someone while others will really love them and vice versa…

        Login or Register before you can reply to HeTieShou
  9. Liam says:

    There’s a fine line between wooden n otherwise…haha.
    Some audience is more discerning than others.
    “Love is not made to order” You have had been fair in most of your review but it’s human nature to be subjective n take it as conclusive.
    Everyone has a right to his/her own view and nothing in this world has a fixed answer
    So for me and many others, Niki is GREAT!
    She does not make me squirm and engage me comfortably.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Liam
    • Funn Lim replied:

      Exactly! That fine line is determined by fans and critics alike. Doesn’t mean I am biased though. I do think she is wooden. But others may agree or disagree.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Funn Lim
      • Funn Lim replied:

        And no no she didn’t make me squirm but didn’t make me feel OH I MUST WATCH THIS FOR HER. Frankly she is just there.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Funn Lim
      • Vivien replied:

        and for others she has a better charisma than overused TVB fadans Myolie Linda Tvia Fala Kate. Tim Sing sees this 😛

        Login or Register before you can reply to Vivien
      • llwy12 replied:

        Funn — I actually agree with you on the ‘wooden’ part (in fact, I actually said so in my review, which I wrote the week the finale aired)…

        Here’s an excerpt from my review that has the commentary about Nikki:

        [Contrary to popular opinion, I actually think that Niki did a decent job in this series. Sure, her acting wasn’t great by any means, but it wasn’t horrible either – I actually did not get as annoyed with her performance in here as I have been in her past series. The problem I’ve always had with Niki’s acting in the past is that she’s too wooden at times, which makes her acting look forced – plus she has a certain intonation in her voice which sometimes makes it sound like she is reading the dialogue rather than reciting it, which is why her acting always comes across as very unnatural to me. That being said though, I will say that she has improved A LOT in this series because even though she still had the same problems (yes, I was able to detect it right away), it was not as pronounced as in previous series. And I have to admit that Niki does crying scenes way better than most of the actresses at TVB nowadays (it’s kind of ironic that I find Niki’s crying scenes quite natural and convincing, but her acting overall doesn’t have the same effect).

        I think that overall, the reason why I found her character tolerable was because of the chemistry that Niki had with Raymond Wong in this series – I actually enjoyed almost every single scene that the 2 of them had together. Perhaps because of Raymond’s great acting in this series, he was able to bring out the best in Niki because I felt that each time the 2 of them interacted in a scene, the emotional impact was very high. I actually think that NIki and Raymond make a great onscreen couple – for me, this was one of the best pairings that I’ve seen in years!]

        Login or Register before you can reply to llwy12
    • Liam replied:

      Ya…
      I agreed she still need to improve but given the fact this is her no.6 serial, she is good.
      I strongly believe with more exposure, she will amaze us very soon.
      AS for TS role, this is her first premodern and she has some reservations abt the acting.
      Give a chance, her performance does not rock but certainly enough to put the top 3 in Jaynestars Poll.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Liam
      • Liam replied:

        Sorry, typo mistakes
        Rush thro my lunch, haha

        Login or Register before you can reply to Liam
    • Veejay replied:

      I also think Niki was quite “wooden” in BP even she has a fresh face as proclaimed by many here who said she’s way better than those overused TVB fadans.

      problem with Niki are she can’t deliver her role effectively and was rather dead aka uninteresting to watch her further progression, the way she carried out her talk in BP sounded so Plain and boring.

      Niki is still pretty though but she needs to learn how to act good with her heart.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Veejay
      • Vivien replied:

        Differently I think Niki is effective and her character can felt. Her series are not as much as other fadans but she has the leading lady look.and fresh charisma

        Login or Register before you can reply to Vivien
      • exoidus replied:

        yeah Niki is kinda wooden, however im rather impressed by her crying skills it looks great unlike Myolie. Think only Linda is better than her with Tavia on the same level or perhaps a little above.

        Anyway BP was always perfect in terms of casting i.e. remove Tracy Ip who can’t really act and look so plastic for some reason to me. What a great series if TVB didn’t ruined in by producing a rubbish ending!

        Login or Register before you can reply to exoidus
      • lol replied:

        Linda and Niki are at the same level while Myolie’s acting is above them. Tavia hard to say

        Login or Register before you can reply to lol
      • exoidus replied:

        i was only talking about “crying” which Niki looks 1 million times better than Myolie!

        overall acting Niki is still a newbie sort of however she is quite natural for someone who don’t have too much experience.

        Unlike some current fadans acting that are too exaggerated!

        Login or Register before you can reply to exoidus
      • Kidd replied:

        I disagree that Nikki is a newbie actress. She might not have acted in many series, but, she has acted in quite a lot of movies.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Kidd
      • exoidus replied:

        a series of 20 epi. provides more acting experience than a movie. I was trying to make a comparison to someone like Myolie who have so many series under her belt.

        So compared to her Niki is kind of a newbie with great potential!

        Login or Register before you can reply to exoidus
    • Kidd replied:

      “Everyone has a right to his/her own view and nothing in this world has a fixed answer”

      But, when that view is not the same as yours, said person is considered as a not discerning audience.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Kidd
      • Liam replied:

        Haha…said person could be that DISCERNING AUDIENCE when he/she finds that an actor is being WOODEN or SUBTLE.
        It’s open-ended.
        Let’s not corner others ideas but try to think out of the hats.
        Individual view is totally subjective based on our own preferences.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Liam
      • Kidd replied:

        Trying to twist you way out of your true meaning won’t work. Now, you make your sentence look like it can go both ways.

        But, can you deny that when you first wrote that sentence, you mean to say ‘the more discerning audience can differentiate subtlety from woodenness’? You are in the ‘Nikki’s acting is great’ camp. Are you going tell me that you have even for 1 second think of yourself as the non-discerning one and Funn (who sees Nikki’s acting as wooden) is the discerning audience.

        Your meaning is subtly worded (pun not intended0 but still very clear.
        ‘There is a fine line between subtle and wooden. A discerning audience can see that. Nikki’s acting is great. She’s not wooden but subtle. But, Funn can’t see this subtlety.’

        Login or Register before you can reply to Kidd
  10. llwy12 says:

    Wow! EXCELLENT review! As a huge fan of the series, I greatly enjoyed reading your review – it was absolutely well-written and so well put together, I felt like I was reading a story itself!

    I actually had no problem with the length of your review because to be quite honest, my reviews are very long as well (though I tend to be more long-winded and go off on tangents often…LOL!)

    Anyway, I absolutely agree with your analysis of the series, though I won’t comment too much here, since I already expressed my thoughts in my review (though you definitely brought out the essence of the series way better than I did, especially with the ‘old-fashioned, chaste romance’ part – that was exactly the sentiment I was trying to express as well, but didn’t do a very good job of….)

    Btw, it’s interesting that you mention the ‘child’ thing because in all honesty, that was what I was hoping for as well — and I will admit that I was initially misled by the promo clips that showed that last scene with Tsui Sum and the little girl that turns out to be her niece (I thought the girl would be her and Boon Sin’s child – probably because I wanted so much for that to happen….).

    In any case….once again, great job with the review!! Absolutely enjoyed reading it!

    Login or Register before you can reply to llwy12
  11. AC says:

    I agree with a lot of what you had to say, but I love Samuel Kwok! I don’t think he’s miscast at all.

    Also, I thought Niki did okay but not outstanding. They basically tailor-made the character for her so I don’t think she could have messed up the role. I just think that she acts the same in every role.

    Login or Register before you can reply to AC
  12. lol says:

    lol Funn ‘s review is a lot more popular and agreed upon than SDS

    Login or Register before you can reply to lol
  13. lol says:

    I mostly agree with Funn but I’ll give Niki.some improved point although I think it’s because she’s acting beside Raymond who is great in his scenes and looks

    Login or Register before you can reply to lol
  14. sandcherry says:

    Funn:

    I enjoyed reading your review very much though it was a bit too long. However, I liked your comments on the acting of various artistes.

    I personally believe that more emphasis should be placed on acting in a review than on the descriptions of the characters. Characters are “deadly” written in a drama, while acting is alive and can be very subjective. As an audience, I would like to be able to tell whose acting is good and whose is not vs. your comments.

    If you can make your analysis shorter on characters, I think your review will be more appealing.

    Login or Register before you can reply to sandcherry
  15. Lynne says:

    Come on, you watch too much TOT!
    I can’t find the last paragraph in Laim,s post!
    Don’t know who twist who, lol

    Login or Register before you can reply to Lynne
  16. Addy says:

    Niki wasn’t that outstanding. She’s basically playing herself, lol. She was neither good nor bad, just doing her job. She gets a bit wooden sometimes, but she did quite well in some emotional parts.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Addy
  17. Allen says:

    Is calling episode 21 garbage too much?? Who the F*** goes to the shore after being stabbed?? Like the Doctor was there trying to help him but he just got up & left. It doesn’t have to end like that, just stupid script writers want to make it dramatic and I can”t believe Lee Tim Shing allows to run with it.

    I was going to give this series 7/10 but after that pathetic ending 5/10 is my max but I want to give it 4/10.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Allen
  18. Allen says:

    Nothing really stood out for me this series. But the acting was above average; I saw a lot of improvements from Niki & Elaine; it’s great to see Eric Li playing a good person role, he’s very talented.

    In addition, I’m not sure where I am with Niki being the milk candy girl. Like I felt her adoptive mother treats her better than her own son considering it’s the 30s.

    I think they could’ve done something interesting as to have Milk Candy girl being a different person.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Allen