Review: Curse of the Royal Harem (By Bridget)

By on January 27, 2012 in NEWS, REVIEWS

pic

Curse of the Royal Harem <萬凰之王>
TVB 2011
Producer: Chong Wai Kin
Genre: Historical Fiction
Number of episodes: 27 in Hong Kong (29 Overseas)

Rating:

Cast of Characters

Jessica Hsuan as “Yee Lan”
Myolie Wu as “Yuen Yuen”
Nancy Wu as “Choi Lam”
Sunny Chan as “Emperor Do Kwong”
Joel Chan as “Min Yan”
Gigi Wong as “Empress Dowager”
Cheung Kwok Keung as “Wai Fuk On”

Foreword

Not War and Beauty, that’s for sure.

Review 

It’s been awhile since I’ve watched a TVB series and that’s because I’ve become indifferent.  Thinking Curse of the Royal Harem would at least bring about a reaction out of this nearly dead soul (TVB-wise, at least), I picked up this series after the holidays.  And I watched it. And then…

I didn’t know what to think.

This series reminds me of the tagline from MTV’s Diary: “You think you know, but you have no idea.”  I give props to the writers for attempting something unconventional among the usual concubine-fighting storylines, but the result is a theme that is loftily explained, and a series that ends up missing the mark by a few thousand miles.  Curse of the Royal Harem gets points for trying, and then proceeds to lose them all (and then some) for execution.

Jess… oh Jess.  She gets off on the wrong foot (not her fault though) immediately because she doesn’t work in an ancient series.  She’s like Flora Chan in ancient series minus the Western accent.  Her look is too modern, not to mention she is way too old for her role.  I think of Yee Lan as a young widow, maybe in her mid-20s at the most, and Jess, while
looking good for her age, looks…seasoned.  I kept thinking of the buzzer sound (you know, the “ehhhhhh you’re wrong” buzzer sound in game shows) whenever she was onscreen.  Period elegance?  Buzzer.  Period grace?  Buzzer.  Period femininity?  Buzzer.  Just like Kevin Cheng’s first scene in Beyond the Realm of Conscience, I laughed when Jess made
her appearance.  A flower enthusiast?!  Please, the woman is more convincing as a news anchor.  Not that they had those back then. 

There are two main issues with Jess here.  One is her voice; it’s monotone.  She tries hard to be feminine, gentle, and quiet as Yee Lan but instead her voice comes off as robotic.  The other is her acting; she doesn’t look burdened or melancholy as Yee Lan is supposed to be. Most of the time, she just looks annoyed.  Patience does yield rewards here as Jess’ performance in the later part of Curse of the Royal Harem gradually improves–a little.  Her single best moment was when Yee Lan was faced with a dilemma of whether to save Yuen Yuen’s son and her choice at the end. Ultimately though, Jess’ performance is thin, bland, and does nearly nothing to engage the audience.

Myolie Wu treads the same path as Jess in here, but for different reasons.  In the beginning, Jess underacted, while Myolie overacted. The bulging eyes, the constant head movements, the overdone pout…. I was almost reminded of her awful performance in War of In-Laws (which very nearly turned me from a Myolie fan to an anti-fan).  Both Myolie’s performance and the character of Yuen Yuen came off as childish, stupid, and somewhat aimless when everything was stripped away.  Yuen Yuen was little more than a puppet of her mother’s.  She never seemed ambitious on her own or particularly thirsty for power; everything she did seemed to be just for the goal of pleasing her mother.  A poorly written character – the scriptwriters tried to create a Kam Ling from Beyond the Realm of Conscience and instead ended up more with a Yee Sun from War & Beauty--nothing more than a puppet who never really reached her potential as a villain.  Ironically, Myolie improves dramatically once her character becomes less interesting–that is, when she is banished to the cold palace.  I see glimmers of her innocence and child-woman-ness from her Golden Faith and Doomed to Oblivion performances, and her character becomes much easier to empathize with because of that.

Yes, I know Myolie won Best Actress for this.  Don’t ask me how.  I’m just a reviewer, man.

Despite the name and intent of the series, the men manage to be just as, if not more, interesting than the women in here. 

Joel Chan, in the midst of his offscreen media circus with socialite Florinda Ho, performs gamely as Min Yan.  The anger, the courage, the longing for Yuen Yuen, the guilt about Lok Yan and even to an extent, Min Yan’s integrity, were all convincingly portrayed and he does have the look of a young military general from the era.  And he has chemistry with Myolie.  Easily one of the best performances in the series. 

You know, Min Yan really should have been king.  He’s decisive; he has an opinion; he has a spine.  The problem with him is that he is a die hard romantic, which is something that I actually like in the character. He is loyal, not only to the woman he loves but faithful to his brother and king.  So he did sleep with Yuen Yuen, but that was because he really loved her.  It was never meant as an act of malice towards his brother and he remains faithful to the end, even silently allowing his real son to be known as his brother’s son.  He could have easily joined forces with his mother to usurp the throne, but never did the thought even cross his mind.  The king was lucky to have him as a brother and servant.  For once I was glad Min Yan didn’t descend into villain hood and I think of his end as fitting and a good thing for a good character. He died with Yuen Yuen, knowing she loved him.  It was an anti-climatic, but romantic scene. 

Sunny Chan, who has long been typecast in the weak man characters, does his job as the king.  The desperation to protect Yee Lan, the wimpy crying, the overall weaknesses of the character were well-portrayed.  His character, though, was literally useless.  There is no character arc here, he goes from a little useless, to more useless, and then completely useless.  I thought the whole opium storyline would have given the king some kind of development, but nothing really happened there.  The fact that he allowed Min Yan and Yuen Yuen’s son to not just live, but live as the second prince was indicative of not the
character’s compassion, but utter uselessness, weakness and indecisiveness in the face of challenge.  That plot in itself was illogical and a huge plot hole, no way in hell would a bastard child have survived back then, even with a useless king. Someone like an eunuch, minister, older concubine or even the Dowager Empress would have offed the kid (despite him being her biological grandchild).  If he had loved Yee Lan single-mindedly (like the series suggested at the beginning), the character would have had so much more potential and could have amounted to something like Louis Koo’s Qian Long from War and Remembrance.  Instead, the king here just appears fickle and childish with his very flavour-of the-month treatment of his women. 

The Dowager Empress made no sense to me.  She propped up her adopted son to be king out of guilt for accidentally killing his mother and basically raised him as one of her own, but what made her ultimately try and prop her own son as king instead?  Was the guilt only temporary? The series never explained this and I was left very confused.  The
acting was a yawn too.  Gigi Wong has never been a strong veteran actress and her performance is tepid at best.  While she has the looks of a Dowager Empress, she acted more worried than sinister half the time.  Elena Kong was scarier than her.  They should have switched roles because Elena also looks regal and something about her eyes and overall demeanor is intimidating and I am sure she could have done the Dowager
Empress justice. 

I finally know who Sire Ma is after watching this series.  Her performance is adequate here; her voice is appropriately young for the role, and she is cute, eager, and even somewhat sweet as Lok Yan.  She’s rather plain-looking, but acting-wise I would say she has potential, which is a good thing because God knows there’s almost no one left in
TVB to act in series.

I normally like Nancy Wu but something about her irked me in here.  I will blame it on inconsistency in her performance and even a bit of overacting, as well as a one-dimensional character who really does nothing to add value to the plot and her own character arc was flat. She was selfish from beginning to end; that’s it.  And the way she
became concubine was even more idiotic than On Sin from War and Beauty

Cheung Kwok Keung as Eunuch Fuk On was exceptional, as were Rebecca Chan and the older actors who portrayed the ministers in this series. Unfortunately, the girls who played the other concubines were terrible. Even the costumes and setting leave something to be desired.  The cast looks like a rich scholarly family, instead of royalty.  TVB must be running out of money.

To Watch or Not To Watch, That is the Question

Let’s just say this series is difficult to recommend…and life is challenging enough as it is, isn’t it?

   

This review was written by Bridget, a Contributing Writer at JayneStars.com. Visit Bridget’s blog!

30 comments to Review: Curse of the Royal Harem (By Bridget)

  1. someone says:

    This series makes me hate TVB. Why Myolie? I must see her from series to series. TVB should have given her breaking-time because she needs to rest and because….she cannot act well. Giving her some time to think about what kind of career she should be in in case she feels unable to be sucessful is not bad idea.

    Yes, she got her best actress award and living on the top of the world now but what will happen if she cannot have this award in her future? She again will tell the news she has wanted to give up.

    At least, she will focus more on Mainland series this year. Time to enjoy other actresses!!!!!!!!!!

    Login or Register before you can reply to someone
  2. Addy says:

    Myolie shouldn’t have won Best Actress at all, period. But out of her contenders, she was indeed the one who stood out the most.

    And I agree with your review! Min-yan was my favorite character, and Joel Chan deserved some recognition for his portrayal.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Addy
    • HeTieShou replied:

      I think Myolie won because there were no other strong contenders.We also all know that the awards are often rigged as well so why are we all so shocked??? I feel that the awards that mean anything anymore…

      Login or Register before you can reply to HeTieShou
      • Addy replied:

        I wasn’t shocked. I was expecting her to win, but if I were to choose 2011’s Best Actress, it would be Yoyo Mung (and if TVB is anything similar the Oscars, Elena Kong would have won lol).

        We all know the awards are rigged, but these awards still mean something. Both Kevin Cheng and Myolie Wu got a lot more jobs after winning, and their prices went up. Ben Wong and Sharon Chan’s popularity soared.

        But since there will be more free stations this year (aka more nonTVB dramas), maybe a new awards show will appear so everything related to HK television will not be as TVB biased. Similar to Taiwan’s Golden Bell awards.

        Login or Register before you can reply to Addy
  3. tippani says:

    Bridget, I always love reading your reviews, evn for the ones I haven’t seen, because of your witty comments on how absolutely painful to watch tvb is getting. lol your last sentence. Tvb is so cheap with its budget lately, even if the story is good I’m finding it so hard to watch and so easy to make fun of because of the terrible lighting, over acting, over used music etc. I know I sound really b***** but I think it’s about time TVB UNDERGOES SOME CHANGE AND STOPS RELEASING BAD DRAMA AFTER BAD DRAMA

    /ex-tvb fan, grew up watching, pity to see how stanky it’s become now. darn u corrupt tvb execs

    Login or Register before you can reply to tippani
    • Bridget replied:

      Thanks, tippani for the compliment!

      As painful as TVB has become as of late, I just can’t get away from them completely. It’s like a bandaid permanently fused to my skin. I grew up with them, after all. 😉

      Login or Register before you can reply to Bridget
  4. sandcherry says:

    I like this kind of review. The analysis of the acting vs. characters are well analyzed and defined here. The review is the best one I have ever read in this Forum …. well written but not too long. In the previous reviews, I think too much was written on the characters vs. acting. If you watch a drama series, you should be able to find out the details from the drama, and do not have to read the detailed review first. It is always better to watch the acting to learn about the characteristics of the characters.

    Very well written and I enjoyed reading this review.

    Login or Register before you can reply to sandcherry
  5. sandcherry says:

    Joel Chan was the best artiste in CRH, and Nancy Wu was the second best …… better than Jessica Husan and way better than Myolie Wu.

    Login or Register before you can reply to sandcherry
    • HeTieShou replied:

      What did you think of Rebecca Chan’s performance?? She is a veteran actress so her acting should be good…

      Login or Register before you can reply to HeTieShou
  6. sandcherry says:

    Gigi Wong was terrible, too, same as Myolie Wu. Cheung Kwok Kueng was quite decent in his acting, so was Sire Ma.

    Login or Register before you can reply to sandcherry
  7. iampheng says:

    Honestly, this series was extremely disappointing.

    Login or Register before you can reply to iampheng
  8. sandcherry says:

    Rebecca Chan’s performance was quite good, but her screen time was not a lot.

    I don’t like Sunny Chan’s performance either. He was such an “undecided” king, no authority and no power. He only impressed me in the whole drama series when he was addicted to opium.

    Login or Register before you can reply to sandcherry
  9. sandcherry says:

    Bridget
    I really liked the way you wrote your review, short but right to the point. Moreover, I totally agree with your analyses and comments on the artistes’ acting (except maybe Nancy Wu ….. I still think she acted quite well …. much better than the other female lead artistes). I can’t comment on Elena Kong because I missed watching some episodes because the drama series was so boring …. nothing but just fights between Jessica and Myolie. I am sure Elena Kong should be good ….. she always acted well in her characters. She will definitely do a better job than Gigi Wong, but I think her age is a bit young for the Dowager Empress.

    I hope to see more reviews written in this way … short but right to the point.

    Thanks, Bridget.

    Login or Register before you can reply to sandcherry
    • Bridget replied:

      Thanks sandcherry for the compliment! Nancy was better than Myolie and Jess for sure, although I think she’s done better in the past (No Regrets, for example).

      Login or Register before you can reply to Bridget
  10. sandcherry says:

    ” …… because God knows there’s almost no one left in TVB to act in series” ……. totally agree!

    Login or Register before you can reply to sandcherry
    • Bridget replied:

      Or at least, no one left in TVB who doesn’t give me hives watching them. 😉 Thanks for the comments!

      Login or Register before you can reply to Bridget
  11. sandcherry says:

    I don’t think Myolie Wu’s acting deserved her the Best Actress Award. Myolie is okay in acting some “over-exaggerated” roles in comedies, but definitely not a serious and villainous role and someone with dignity, such as the queen in CRH. She “overacted. The bulging eyes, the constant head movements, the overdone pout….” I only saw 2 types of facial expressions from her ….. happy and angry, plus she spoke her words too fast, and it was difficult to understand her. Did not like her at all, though Jessica’s acting was not amazing either. Jessica’s voice was very bland and monotonous. Bridget, you are right on.

    Login or Register before you can reply to sandcherry
    • Addy replied:

      Because this is TVB and they have been literally blueprinting Myolie’s road to Best Actress success, it’s not at all surprising that she won for this role. Her acting in CRH definitely wasn’t Best Actress material, but out of her contenders, she did give the strongest performance.

      But like what I said earlier, if I was TVB and I didn’t give a **** about all that managerial biological son/daughter crap, I would give the award to Yoyo Mung or Elena Kong.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Addy
  12. Jasmine says:

    Great review! Not too long yet the gist is adequate. I really could not stand Jessica’s fake ‘quietly elegant’ voice and really she was a miscast. Myolie was better towards the end and I too really liked Joel Chan in this (and also in Bottled Passion).

    The dowager was VERY boring although I don’t really agree she has the looks of a dowager either hehe…

    Login or Register before you can reply to Jasmine
  13. khanh says:

    okay i was waiting for this series to come out for heaps long. and i was so excited to watch it because i thought it would be another good ancient drama but when i started to watch it, it was just a disappointment. overall it was alright but it wasnt good.

    Login or Register before you can reply to khanh
  14. Grace says:

    Like Joel Chan’s character, the acting is pretty good too.
    Agree Dowager’s acting is bad- haha not evil looking at all.
    I thought Jessica look very good but her character should have been better developed.
    Sunny Chan is down right boring!
    Have always like Cheung Kwok Kueng, he never failed to disappoint.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Grace
  15. Lilly says:

    Isn’t there 31 eps for this?

    Login or Register before you can reply to Lilly
  16. irislim says:

    Thanks for this review. I was wondering to watch it or not. Bridget, is this you from spcnet?

    Login or Register before you can reply to irislim
  17. Bridget says:

    Iris,

    Bah I’ve been IDed! Just kidding. 🙂 Yes, I’m the same Bridget from SPCnet. Did SC forget to pay her bills? I got some weird page the last time I tried to visit the site.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Bridget
    • irislim replied:

      Bridget! I don’t know if you still remember me, hehe. I should start writing reviews again like you still are =D I still trust your taste. Lemme know if any good dramas come up 😉

      Login or Register before you can reply to irislim
      • Bridget replied:

        Of course I remember you, Iris! Haha, yes, definitely, start writing reviews again! The net is missing some good, thoughtful reviewers lately… although I can sometimes understand why (it gets tiring after awhile).

        Trust my taste??? Eek, that is pressure. LOL. Are you talking about TVB dramas, are just any good drama to recommend?

        Login or Register before you can reply to Bridget
  18. sandcherry says:

    Where is this website “JayneStars.com”? Is it in New York? I think it is not a Hongkong website. Am I right? I believe that all the reviewers are overseas Chinese.

    Login or Register before you can reply to sandcherry
    • Jayne replied:

      Sandcherry,
      Yes I’m in New York, but our Contributing Writers come from all across the world, North America, Asia-Pacific, Europe, etc.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Jayne
  19. Hannah says:

    i think myolie is well-deserved with awards withh all her hard work and she performeded very well.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Hannah
  20. sandcherry says:

    Jayne:

    Thanks for your info. I enjoyed reading all the news/articles posted on this website. I live in Canada. After learning about your website, I can get 1st hand news about Hong Kong artistes.

    You guys are marvellous!

    Login or Register before you can reply to sandcherry