Review: “Queens of Diamonds and Hearts” (By H)

By on April 9, 2012 in NEWS, REVIEWS

pic

Queens of Diamonds and Hearts <東西宮略>
Hong Kong TVB Drama, 2012

Producer: Wong Wai Sing
Genre: Historical Fiction, Comedy
Number of Episodes: 25

Rating: 

Cast

Roger Kwok as “King Chai Suen”
Fala Chen as “Chung Mo Yim”
Sharon Chan as “Ha Ying Chun”
Louis Yuen as “Ngan Ying”
Ben Wong as “Lord Shun Yeung Kwan”
Raymond Cho as “Keung Chik Yan”
Koni Lui as “Chung Mo Wai”

 *Spoilers Alert*

Synopsis

King Chai Suen (Roger Kwok) is the incompetent ruler of the State of Qi. A stroke of fate brings the King to meet Chung Mo Yim (Fala Chen), a smart, skilled and strategic woman. However, she was born with a hideous birth mark on her face and the King finds it revolting. Due to a promise made, the King is forced to make Mo Yim his wife despite his own unwillingness to do so.

At the same time, the King meets Ha Ying Chun (Sharon Chan) and immediately falls in love with her beauty, promising that she will become his wife as well. So the day comes and Mo Yim becomes the Queen of the East Palace and Ying Chun becomes the Queen of the West Palace.

Initially, the marriages went well as Mo Yim deals with the State’s affairs and problems, while the King spends time with the beautiful Ying Chun. Howeve,r tensions rise as the King slowly develops a liking for Mo Yim after she rescues him countless times. The result is Ying Chun’s jealously, which makes her an easy tool to those who wish to kill the King.

Theme Song: Fala Chen is not a bad singer!

Review

Commentary regarding the early, middle, and ending episodes are below:

Early Episodes: At first I did o’t realize it was a comedy but once I started the first episode, I knew right away. The first few episodes were actually quite uneventful and the humour that was used was not too engaging or funny.

With the characters, viewers can see that Ying Chun is a very naïve and innocent girl with a terrible past. She was a likable character in the beginning but her stupidity (or rather ignorance) allowed her to be fooled by the lies her family told about Mo Yim. This made her jealous and caused her dislike Mo Yim. This is probably the first time Sharon Chan had a lead role (or one of them) in a drama but the character itself is pretty shallow and does not stir much emotion.

Playing the King, Roger Kwok was back to his old silly self and played his role accordingly. I have no other comment.

Fala Chen is convincing when it comes to being a rough person from the “mountains” but her birthmark just doesn’t seem that ugly! Past actresses that played Chung Mo Yim were a lot uglier! I don’t think Fala looks that natural in ancient dramas. She looks better in modern ones.

Also, Koni Lui’s voice is very annoying at times.

To be honest, there’s not much to comment on in the first few episodes.

The Middle Episodes/Rising Action: When Mo Yim started to like the King and vice versa, that’s where things got interesting. The plot quickened as well as the humour! I chuckled a few times as I watched the rising action of the story. One of the funniest and unique twists in the drama was when the King and Mo Yim switched souls! It was strange, yet fun to watch and kudos to the writer for adding it in! Then, when I thought that they would switch back their souls, something else happened…which I won’t ruin for you!

Now behind all this, Lord Shun Yeung Kwan (Ben Wong) is plotting something evil! Well needless to say, he was planning to take the throne! Just like most ancient costume dramas, someone wants to be king. In the midst of all the humor among the other characters, Ben plans to usurp the throne.

This is where I got really frustrated.

How can the characters be so stupid? I know it’ll make the story fit together perfectly if they’re that stupid but it just makes me want to yell in frustration! Come on! I rather have a longer series than have a forced storyline! Sometimes I feel that TVB just rushes its dramas too much. I mean, many of China’s dramas are 50+ episodes long! Maybe it’s the fast and quick lifestyle of Hong Kong.

Acting wise, I really enjoyed watching Fala and her comedic side! When she was acting as the King, it was really good and funny to watch! I think she did well in a comedy series! Some over-attempts to be funny but in a comedic, light hearted drama like this, I think it wasn’t too bad.

For Sharon (Ying Chun), I think she didn’t have enough scenes with opportunities for her to “shine.” But I think she mastered the “cooing” when she is trying to seduce the King. I’m glad she got one of the main roles because normally she is a supporting character even though she’s been with TVB for a decade already.

As for Roger, I think he did a good job in this drama.

Supporting characters played by actors/actresses such as Oscar Leung, Louis Yuen, Yoyo Chen, Koni Lui and Raymond Cho weren’t bad. Oscar, Louis and Koni were amusing, Raymond was a bit emotionless and Yoyo was a bit over-dramatic. But maybe she did that to be funnier.

The End/Climax: Utterly disappointing.

The “climax” or the most exciting part of the drama was just not very exciting; typical and anti-climatic. I think that it was supposed to be really “thrilling” when the King was about to get killed. But then the writers used the same trick again (switching souls) and then you realize how dumb the whole thing is.

The fall of the villain was terrible as well. Yes, his trusted one betrayed him and in the end, he became a crazy person who thinks he’s the king. Sounds a lot like Beyond the Realm of Conscience and The Life and Times of a Sentinel. Seriously, TVB has to kill some of its villains! Give the bad guys what they deserve!

BUT it IS a comedy so of course there is a happy ending! If you are a person who hates tragic endings, you are in for a treat.

In the last few episodes, I don’t really see much stand-outs in the acting, so I would have to say that the end wasn’t really as intense as I wanted it to be.

Other Things:  I’ve read that many think that Sharon should have played Mo Yim instead and that they should have switched roles. In my opinion, I believe that Sharon was good for the role as she had to be slightly evil and be able to look desirable. With Fala, I just can’t see her be someone fragile yet “evil.” Sharon can be rough and tough, but I don’t think she’ll look as good as Fala when doing fighting scenes or comedic scenes.

However, I don’t think that Ying Chun was evil enough. She could have been so much more evil if she wasn’t so ignorant and oblivious of her surroundings.

If Mo Yim’s Master is even capable of switching souls, why can’t she simply make Mo Yim’s birthmark disappear? That’s something I don’t understand. But I like how they made the relation that the birthmark looks like the map of Qi so she is destined to help the king. That was creative.

I’ve never seen the Princess in another drama before. I thought she was cute and I hope to see her more!

Bottom Line

It was a simple and cheerful drama. Doesn’t have a really clear objective and it’s plainly there for fast, short-term entertainment. The beginning and end were disappointing the humour and plot in the middle saves it. Ratings for the finale were a bit high and I think that the ratings in the middle of the series could have been higher. That’s all!

This review was written by H, a Contributing Writer at JayneStars.com.

21 comments to Review: “Queens of Diamonds and Hearts” (By H)

  1. anoninhk says:

    Even Sharon is too pretty for the role of Mo Yim. They should have made the birthmark even uglier with additional zits, scars and hairy moles or cast another actress altogether. No offence to her fans but Koni might have made a more convincing Mo Yim. Or even an older actress like Louisa So since Mo Yim was supposed to have been around 40 when she married the emperor.

    Login or Register before you can reply to anoninhk
    • Amy replied:

      Fala is the one who played Mo Yim… Sharon played Ying Chun..

      Login or Register before you can reply to Amy
      • anoninhk replied:

        Heya, that’s my response to people suggesting that Fala and Sharon switch roles… I think even Sharon is too pretty to play Mo Yim, never mind Fala.

        Login or Register before you can reply to anoninhk
    • josie replied:

      The reality is that people don’t wanna turn on their tv to see ugly, especially when eating dinner.

      Login or Register before you can reply to josie
      • TVBaddict replied:

        exactly. they wanna see like a cute couple…. not some ugly 40-year-old women with a cute king like roger 🙂

        Login or Register before you can reply to TVBaddict
  2. lilangel0789 says:

    “One of the funniest and unique twists in the drama was when the King and Mo Yim switched souls! It was strange, yet fun to watch and kudos to the writer for adding it in…”

    I wouldn’t give the writer so much credit for writing it; hardly original. Blatantly inspired by the Korean drama, Secret Garden. Not to say the soul switching idea originated from there either, but if you compare the two scenes from both dramas, you’ll definitely notice the similarities.

    Login or Register before you can reply to lilangel0789
    • lilangel0789 replied:

      **if you compare the two scenes from when they first switched in both dramas…

      Login or Register before you can reply to lilangel0789
    • Fox replied:

      Changing souls appeared in many other countries’ works, not only in this Secret Garden. Don’t give it so much credit. I’ve watched both and I don’t find it is too similar, but it’s nearer to Boku to Kanojo no Peke Mittsu

      Login or Register before you can reply to Fox
  3. lilangel0789 says:

    And I’m surprised to see you rated this series so highly. Mediocre acting from the cast and poorly written script.

    The series got boring quite early on; 25 episodes was a stretch, I was expecting it to end at 20. If it’s not because of my habit to finish dramas no matter how much I hate it, I would’ve stopped watching in the first half.

    The ending was a disappointment, though I didn’t have high expectations to begin with.

    I would rate this a 2/5 at best.

    Login or Register before you can reply to lilangel0789
  4. fez says:

    It was boring. Worse adaptation of the Mo Yim story. Script was really bad, acting was bad, everyone was too pretty, everyone had a happy ending. too easy. no suspense, no climax.

    Login or Register before you can reply to fez
  5. tirah says:

    I watched the first 2 episodes… I usually enjoy comedy but the humor was just really stupid and lame…that seems to be the trend with TVB lately… I want to continue watching it because I really like Fala but I don’t know… Roger seems like he’s overacting a bit and is it just me or does he look like he got botox????

    Login or Register before you can reply to tirah
  6. Hi says:

    I think Fala actually really fit the role Mo Yim cuz just copying other old dramas and making Mo Yim REALLY UGLY then I dont see a point of watching it! Anyways if Mo Yim is too ugly it wouldn’t make sense when the king say ” this ugly woman will actually look cute without her birthmark! ” >.<

    Login or Register before you can reply to Hi
  7. Hannahh says:

    i stop watching the series @ episode4. i always enjoy comedy series but this series was quite lame and honestly i don’t like Fala and she can’t act(sorry fala’s fan). The story wasn’t very convincing.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Hannahh
  8. Addy says:

    I pretty much stopped watching TVB comedies after Virtues of Harmony, which was, IMO, the last sincerely hilarious sitcom/drama produced by TVB.

    My favorite TVB comedies are the 1980 minidrama “Don’t Look Now” and the record-breaking “War of the Genders.” Absolutely hilarious. I lost count of how many times I’ve rewatched them, and still, after so many years of watching, they’re still funny, clever, and witty.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Addy
    • phoebe replied:

      you’re right! Virtues of Harmony is the BEST sitcom of ALL TIME. when it ended I felt like crying because I’ve been attached by them SO MUCH >_<

      Login or Register before you can reply to phoebe
  9. SDS says:

    You are definitely not giving this series the amount of vomit inducing credit this stores deserves.

    Login or Register before you can reply to SDS
  10. H says:

    Maybe my expectationsa are just too low 🙂

    Login or Register before you can reply to H
  11. #someday says:

    i haaaaated the ending dafuq! clearly the king should have ended up with mo yim, and the other girl should ended with raymond cho…-.- not convince he loves both of them.

    Login or Register before you can reply to #someday
  12. mobsquad says:

    I agree with the story that it is dark comedy; though some of the characters just are so moronic. only in the first set of the series currently on the 10th chapter. Not bad but could be better; roger playing the king is spectacular and Sharon chan;with her birthmark still is pretty. Not much to say about the rest except it feels like it is almost over only at 10th episode( maybe a little bit longer.

    Login or Register before you can reply to mobsquad
  13. Kidd says:

    I’ve watched up to 2/3 of this drama. I think Fala acted very well as Chung Mo Yim. She has great comic sense.

    Login or Register before you can reply to Kidd
    • Kidd replied:

      I especially like her acting when Mo Yim and King changed soul. Her facial expression is so like the king. Very funny.

      Login or Register before you can reply to Kidd